Shattering the Mac OS X ‘security through obscurity’ myth

“The real reason no viruses exist for Mac OS X has little to do with its low market share… but rather its near-impenetrability,” many of David Zeiler’s readers pointed out in a barrage of critical email missives responding to Zeiler’s inclusion of a quote from an anti-virus software firm’s consultant. The quote intimated that Mac OS X has no more inherent security than Windows.

Zeiler reports, “Though many amateurs may be looking for, and finding, holes in Windows, the FreeBSD Unix code that forms the foundation of OS X has been prodded by legions of expert programmers for 30 years. Though a few hardy souls use the Unix offshoot Linux on PCs built for Windows — they usually wipe Windows off the hard drive — Unix typically is used in mission-critical roles, powering high-end work stations and file servers.”

“And, as mentioned earlier, crackers prefer hitting targets that will cause maximum disruption. ‘Many orders of magnitude more people look over the source code for OS X and the related BSDs than have access to Windows source code,’ said John Klos, a developer of NetBSD, a flavor of Unix closely related to OS X,” Zeiler reports.

“Thus, many of the obvious holes in OS X were closed years ago. That, some suggested, actually makes OS X a more attractive target. ‘If I were a fame-driven cracker with solid technical skills, cracking a BSD-based system would be the fastest way to show off my capabilities,’ said Rich Morin, a programmer and consultant based in San Bruno, Calif. ‘My suspicion, therefore, is that many crackers have tried this challenge and failed,’ Morin added. Still, he cautioned ‘nobody has any way to know for sure,'” Zeiler reports.

Full (long) article here.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
Apple’s Mac OS X is simply much more secure than Micorosft’s Windows XP – February 01, 2005
Windows’ mounting security problems make some consumers eager to purchase Macs – January 03, 2005
Windows Media songs and videos found to carry Windows malware payloads – December 30, 2004
Anzae/Inzae worm affects all Windows versions after 3.1; Macintosh unaffected – December 28, 2004
Unlike Windows users, Mac OS X users surf the Internet without a care in the world – December 28, 2004
Multiple unpatched Windows holes crop up; Windows systems compromised within minutes in experiment – December 24, 2004
Windows spyware mess is out of control, get a Mac and surf with impunity – December 21, 2004
New Microsoft Internet Explorer exploit spoofs Web sites on fully patched Windows XP systems – December 17, 2004
Microsoft may charge extra for Windows spyware protection software – December 16, 2004
Detroit Free Press: Windows malware problem getting worse, it’s time to get a Mac instead – December 16, 2004
Sick of spyware, adware headaches? Get a Mac and surf the Internet freely – December 13, 2004
Mossberg: Windows PCs plagued with problems, Apple’s Mac is ‘rock solid, elegant and affordable’ – December 09, 2004
Security expert: Don’t use Microsoft Windows, Office, Outlook, Internet Explorer – December 09, 2004
Security test: Windows XP system easily compromised while Apple’s Mac OS X stands safe and secure – November 30, 2004
Sick of spyware, adware infecting your PC? Don’t fret, just get a Mac – November 01, 2004
Microsoft: The safest way to run Windows is on your Mac – October 08, 2004
Spyware plagues Windows users while Mac users surf Net with impunity – November 01, 2004
Ballmer blames Windows users for not upgrading systems as Microsoft’s biggest security problem – October 22, 2004
Windows users line up to pay for spyware removal; Mac users surf Web with impunity – October 18, 2004
Microsoft: The safest way to run Windows is on your Mac – October 08, 2004
Windows users’ security woes spark interest in Apple’s secure Mac OS X – October 06, 2004
Windows desktop monopoly threatened by secure, safe Apple Mac OS X – October 04, 2004
Even Bill Gates can’t avoid Windows malware; Mac users surf the Web freely – October 03, 2004
Cyber-security adviser uses Apple Macintosh to avoid Windows’ security woes – September 27, 2004
Information Security Investigator says switch from Windows to Mac OS X for security – September 24, 2004
Mossberg: Apple iMac G5 ‘powerful, affordable, virus-free with better, more modern OS than Windows XP’ – September 23, 2004
USA Today: people are switching from Windows to Mac because of security issues – September 21, 2004
Windows besieged by hackers; number of Windows viruses soars by more than 400% – September 20, 2004
USA Today columinst angry about Windows viruses, adware, spyware – September 15, 2004
University of Chicago recommends all students patch Windows at least once a day – September 14, 2004
Windows XP worm speaks to users as it deletes their files; Macintosh unaffected – September 13, 2004
Security is top priority in Apple’s Mac OS X – September 12, 2004
Millions of Windows PC’s hijacked by hackers, turned into zombies; Macintosh unaffected – September 08, 2004
Mossberg: Dump your Windows machine and get an Apple Macintosh to free yourself of spyware – August 25, 2004
Tired of patching patches to patch Windows patches? Writer suggests getting a Mac – August 03, 2004
Windows ‘Scob’ virus designed to steal financial data, passwords; Macintosh unaffected – June 26, 2004
Gartner: Worms jack up the total cost of Microsoft Windows – May 07, 2004
Spyware, adware plague Windows users online; Mac OS X users surf freely – April 19, 2004
SmartMoney: Long-suffering Windows users can only dare to dream of Mac’s ease-of-use – February 12, 2004
Mac OS X has no viruses; what’s wrong with Windows? – February 11, 2004
Gates: Windows ‘by far the most secure’ system; tries to use ‘Mac OS X secure through obscurity’ myth – January 27, 2004
Columnist tries the ‘security through obscurity’ myth to defend Windows vs. Macs on virus front – October 1, 2003
New York Times: Mac OS X ‘much more secure than Windows XP’ – September 18, 2003
Wall Street Journal’s Mossberg on making the switch from Windows to Mac – September 18, 2003
Fortune columnist: ‘get a Mac’ to thwart viruses; right answer for the wrong reasons – September 02, 2003
Shattering the Mac OS X ‘security through obscurity’ myth – August 28, 2003
Is Mac OS X really inherently more secure than Windows? – August 26, 2003
Chicago Sun-Times columnist: Windows ‘many holes in its security’ but ‘none of my Macs have ever been affected – August 26, 2003
Sick of worms and viruses? ‘Move to Mac OS X’ suggests Chicago Tribune columnist – August 25, 2003
Virus and worm problems not just due to market share; Windows inherently insecure vs. Mac OS X – August 24, 2003

18 Comments

  1. This article should be copied and emailed to journalist out there who says Macs are more secure by their marketshare. This tells it like it really is, in detail. I’ve personally been quite offended by everyone’s “defense” of Microsoft by saying it’s just a marketshare thing. C’mon everyone, start cutting and pasting, and let’s get the facts out there!

  2. Agreed. Virii would be on WIndows even if it had 20% market against 80% of other combined.

    It is the only dumb security-lacking OS that HELPS virii to spread and break havoc on system behind the back of the users.
    I define Windows a traitor-OS : it works against me – the user – and it is a constant threat that requires constant watching. It is ready to stab your back at any moment.

    Linux, OS X, Unix (BSD especially) are allied-OSes. They watch your back and warn you when things are not kosher. They are faithfull lieutenants obeying orders always asking for confirmation prior to execute orders.

    Microsoft executives defined the internet an hostile environment. It is, especially when you OS betrayes you at first occasion.
    Windows users should apply the only firewall to give them true security: BURN the Windows CD and install Linux or get to OS X already!

    Stop infesting the internet with your pests.

  3. I am looking forward to the next worm attack. Gives me a chance to sit back and laugh with satisfaction knowing that all those Mac bashing jerks are once again living in hell! LOL!

    Its the true PAYBACK we Mac users have against the ignorant, arrogant misguided idiocy we are forced to endure at the hands of Wintel trolls and moronic computer industry journalists day in and day out.

    What the article says is so true!

    Since vorus writers are looking for the ultimate “HEY LOOK AT ME!” accomplishment, the cracking of an OS that has remained unbreached for so long would provide the ULTIMATE BRAGGING RIGHTS, but where are those attacks???

    Nowhere to be found.

    You Wintel trolls needs to find something more credible to argue with than this pathetic market share excuse.

    P.S. Apple’s installed base constitutes about 11% of all PCs worldwide.

    This 3% CRAP is nothing more than that…CRAP!

  4. Naawww… I go with “Gates’ Power Trip” theory. Gates is so driven by power and control (see VirtualPC buy out) that his entire purpose for developing Windows was to gain unrestricted access to as many computers as possible. From mom and pop PC’s to see if mom is designing a better can opener in her basement that Gates can steal the patent on, to getting (and selling?) info from governments.

    But, to do this, his OS needs to be loaded with millions of “backdoors”. He uses these for as long as he can until the public awareness of it, then he sloooowly makes a patch that closes one backdoor, but creates another more subtle one. By design, this keeps all of the computers using his OS constantly open to his inspection.

    How did I reach this conclusion? It is either incredibly nieve to leave all of the security wide open on an OS, only to be closed bit-by-bit, or it was intentional. No group of a thousand reasonably intelligent programmers could design such a vulnerable system. It never amazes me how everything Microsoft introduces as “new” has some sort of new vulnerability.

    After 70,000 virii, even if the staff at Microsoft didn’t learn a thing, that 70,000 fewer holes SHOULD slow down the frequency of virus attacks. It’s NOT. It simply looks like someone at home is constantly holding the backdoor wide open regardless of 70,000 “fixes” to keep it closed.

    And, more baffling to me are the consumers…

    Even after 70,000 recall notices, you car still has 2 things go wrong with it each week due to a “design flaw”, would you want to keep it, especially if your neighbor’s car hasn’t seen the shop once since he bought it 4 years ago.?

    �There�s a sucker born every minute, but none of them ever die�, Joseph Bessimer (aka �Paper Collar Joe�)

    …and they just keep buying Windows.

  5. Quote:

    I am looking forward to the next worm attack. Gives me a chance to sit back and laugh with satisfaction knowing that all those Mac bashing jerks are once again living in hell! LOL!

    Its the true PAYBACK we Mac users have against the ignorant, arrogant misguided idiocy we are forced to endure at the hands of Wintel trolls and moronic computer industry journalists day in and day out.
    ————

    what an ATTITUDE!!

    while i enjoy knowing that my Mac if fairly secure, i Do Not Gloat over the fact that Windows user’s have so many virus attacks….

    but, you would think some would consider switching over to Mac’s to avoid such things……

    my 2 cents

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.