Report: Windows XP won’t run on Intel MacBook Pro, iMac

“With the announcement of the first Intel based Macs yesterday, many users have rejoiced in being able to dual-boot both Mac OS X and Windows. Unfortunately, this is not the case; due to Apple’s use of the extensible firmware interface (EFI) rather than BIOS, current Windows releases will not run on the systems,” Nate Mook reports for BetaNews. “On Tuesday at Macworld, Apple senior vice president of worldwide product marketing Phil Schiller said the company would not specifically block the use of Windows on Mac hardware. Instead, limitations in Windows itself will prevent its use on the new MacBook Pro laptop and iMac.”

“With the switch to Intel processors, Apple also moved from Open Firmware to EFI, which is an updated BIOS specification developed by Intel,” Mook reports. “Microsoft’s 64-bit versions of Windows will also not work despite supporting EFI, because Apple’s Intel platform is strictly 32-bit at the moment. For its part, Microsoft encouraged Apple to build hardware compatible with Windows. ‘We have an open specification and a process for certifying the hardware. We welcome all efforts in this area and we’d support Apple the same way we support every other PC manufacturer,’ a company spokesperson told BetaNews. ‘Anyone, including Apple, can purchase and re-sell Windows for use on their industry-standard hardware.'”

Full article with more details and links here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews reader “sailfish” for the link.]

MacDailyNews Note: Extensible Firmware Interface (EFI): Intel-based Macintosh computers use extensible firmware interface (EFI). EFI provides a flexible and adaptable interface between Mac OS X and the platform firmware. This change should be transparent to most developers, but may affect some, such as those who write boot drivers. Source: Apple Developer Connection.

Advertisements:
• MacBook Pro. The first Mac notebook built upon Intel Core Duo with iLife ’06, Front Row and built-in iSight. Starting at $1999. Free shipping.
• iMac. Twice as amazing — Intel Core Duo, iLife ’06, Front Row media experience, Apple Remote, built-in iSight. Starting at $1299. Free shipping.
• iMac and MacBook Pro owners: Apple USB Modem. Easily connect to the Internet using dial-up service. $49.00.
• iPod Radio Remote. Listen to FM radio on your iPod and control everything with a convenient wired remote. Just $49.
• iPod. 15,000 songs. 25,000 photos. 150 hours of video. The new iPod. 30GB and 60GB models start at just $299. Free shipping.
• Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.

50 Comments

  1. Ugh, I just had to swallow hard thinking of Appple as a Windows reseller.

    Not sure how I feel about this, honestly. Seems to me hacks will follow if possible, but with Apple’s popularity growing without Windows, I kinda’ like staying exclusive, I guess.

  2. I kinda’ need to run AutoCAD, but I hate having to use Windows to do so. I’d like to buy Mac for my office – I was hoping they’d be able to run Windows apps. Still stuck, I guess.

  3. The strength of Apple is the integrated hardware and software.

    Quote, “We have an open specification and a process for certifying the hardware. We welcome all efforts in this area and we’d support Apple the same way we support every other PC manufacturer,”

    Yeah well, don’t expect Apple to bend over backwards to get Windows on the Mac, Apple is not into contorting the hardware to match a cobbled OS. Apple is into building stable and reliable platforms.

    MDN magic word – “farm” as in Apple is not specifically farming out their hardware for any old OS.

  4. The article has the tone of apple moved from and open format to a closed one so windows will not work, but it is the case that Apple chose the newest and possibly best open structure that is supported by 64 bit windows but that Microsoft did not add support on XP with it.

    The facts may be accurate, but the tone isn’t. Apple chose a loader method that was newer and more full featured that was not tied to old ways of doing things and MS knew about it when they mad XP but did not chose to support it.

    Hackers will get around this – I suspect XP will be running on the iMacs before the MacBooks hit the street. (This will be a good thing to be able to run a couple of windows games and leave the real work to mac OS X).

  5. It took a few weeks for the hackers to get Mac OS X for Intel running on a non-Apple machine. It will probably take about the same time for them to get Windows running on an Intel Mac. That’ll be good news for architects, realtors, and others that must run Windows software, but I won’t be adding Windows to my Mac any time soon. I see no reason to load up security breaches.

  6. I sold my PowerBook last month with the intention of buying a new Intel Mac laptop so I can run Windows natively. I have a couple particular apps I need that don’t have OS X equivalents. Dang. Now I still have to lug 2 laptops around. Double-dang!

  7. So the new Macs are going to use EFI. Good! One of the biggest gripes about the processor switch among the tech-head crowd was the loss of Open Firmware. EFI’s supposed to be a decent replacement (while BIOS would have been a giant leap backward).

  8. Is it possible the logic is backward here? Apple did this not to prevent Windows from running on their harware, but rather to prevent Mac OS X from running on any old Windows machine for now. This will make it more difficult to hack the OS and run on anything but Apple hardware. It is a layered form of security. Lots of simpler locks instead of one big cumbersome one can be just as secure. My 2 cents.

  9. I also imagine that the open source community will be getting a compatible version of WINE up and running for these Intel based Macs in fairly short order. That would be sufficient for most people that need Windows for just one or two apps.

  10. Wait for DARWINE or CodeWeavers, their software should allow running of non-Vista Windows programs on a Mactel without VPC.

    Microsoft is so behind it’s not even funny, they don’t even have Vista out yet and since they really don’t care, don’t expect anything coming for us in any reasonable time frame.

    Vista will make them money, then Office, then OfficeMac then finally a hobbled VPC.

    Heck Microsoft has to use XCode now instead of CodeWarrior, it’s a intense learning process for them, they can’t even write secure code for their own operating system.

    Gates and Co is still figuring out how to tailor Vista to run on Macs to steal us away from Apple.

    M$ isn’t concerned about hardware sales, but if they can sell Windows to Mac users, they would love that.

    All you fscking traitors will defect in a heartbeat to Vista if it would run on a Mactel.

  11. You run Windows and Windows apps, you’ll have problems whether it be on the new Intel Macs or whatever. The operating system and the software seem to be almost like two squabbling siblings each wanting their own way, neither willing to compromise. And if you boot Windows on one of these new machines, expect Windows viruses. The safest way I know of to run Windows on a Mac would be through VPC, and not allow it to share the Internet connection. Safest way to run Windows on a PC: 1. Best option. Never turn it on. 2. Next best option, never connect to the Internet, install no new software, basically use it as a noisy paperweight, or for Solitaire. 3. Desperation measure when you’ve already gone against options 1 and 2. Remove power cord. Find some creative use for it such as for burning Bill Gates in effigy, or better yet Ballmer or Michael Dell. Fashion it into a whip and flagellate yourself as penance. May lead you to be locked in a loony bin, but taking out your aggression on others would see you locked up in the nearest penitentiary. Maybe you can come up with some better uses.

  12. Wow – this is really good info to know about. Thanks for the article MDN!

    Looks like I’ll have to wait until later this year when Intel releases the 64bit version of the Core Duo, and subsequently when Apple sticks in in the MacBook Pro…

  13. I’m sure the hackers will get there first, but Microsoft will add EFI support to Windows 32-bit with Vista. 64-bit Windows already supports EFI, but the Core Duo CPU is a 32-bit device.

    Wait for Windows VISTA and you will be able to dual boot easily and hack-free.

  14. “I can’t wait to dual-boot Mac OS X and Vista OS X, just to freak out my anti-Apple and anti-Microsoft friends in one fell swoop.”

    Anyone can dual-boot. How ’bout a Classic-like environment with Windows apps running under OS X?

  15. Um, you guys are silly. The Core Duo is a 64 bit chip… it has 2x32bit cores which equals 64 bits!! (yes, that’s a joke Joyce for those w/o a sense of humor and need to have jokes explained.)

    I would argue that it’s up to Microsoft to get Windows working on an Intel Mac (either natively, or via VPC) That is, if they want to see sales of their product on that platform. Why is it Apple’s responsibility to incorporate a downgraded feature set (via BIOS) to support a downgraded OS like Windows? Apple tend to be forward looking. Microsoft look forward (well, ok, across at Apple) but drag the past along with them (seriously, who’s using DOS for anything on a 3.8Ghz Pentium??)

    If Microsoft supported the current state of the art on a 32bit platform, I’m sure it wouldn’t have been too much of an issue.

    Oh well.

  16. SO MUCH FOR MDN’s TAKES ON THE INTEL SWITCH, HUH????

    I mean, c’mon, Apple is losing a TON of sales here. If you could run Windows native right out of the box, every web developer in the world would want those machines. That’s a lot of machines, and a TON of switchers. THIS SUCKS.

  17. Dual cores allow for more applications to be open and running at once. Which is what most people want in their homes and on the road.

    But 64-bits allow for access of larger amounts of RAM, making a single application run faster, good for the hardcore professional.

    Which makes the PowerMac really hard to beat at the high-end: four processors, 64-bit chip, and a built in heater for the room and white noise generator.
    Get some solar panels to power the thing, or at least be willing to pay $10 a month to power the thing if you want to put it in your house and keep it on all the time. Or put it in a room where you can turn off the thermostat for that room, ’cause you won’t need it.

    If you buy bulk electro, or it’s built into the lease, then no problem.

    Fine-tune for a mixture of the two environments.

  18. Gosh… that sucks. Being a XP user myself, I was hoping to consolidate machines. Hopefully MS will continue on with VPC.

    That being said… still buying one of the new MacBook Pros.

    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

  19. Gosh… that sucks. Being a XP user myself, I was hoping to consolidate machines. Hopefully MS will continue on with VPC.

    That being said… still buying one of the new MacBook Pros.

    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

  20. Gosh… that sucks. Being a XP user myself, I was hoping to consolidate machines. Hopefully MS will continue on with VPC.

    That being said… still buying one of the new MacBook Pros.

    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

  21. Gosh… that sucks. Being a XP user myself, I was hoping to consolidate machines. Hopefully MS will continue on with VPC.

    That being said… still buying one of the new MacBook Pros.

    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

  22. I didn’t realize that some people are not familiar with the term “dual boot” in here. It means that you have partitioned your hard drive and set up your bootloader so that, when you turn your computer on, it prompts you for which operating system you want to boot with (which hard drive partition you want to boot from). This will certainly be possible with Windows Vista, since it uses EFI and will support 32 bit CPUs.

    Using an intel Mac set up this way with Vista and Mac OS X, you could use your Mac for everything you can use it for, and reboot into Vista to play the latest games, run Autocad, do your job that requires Windows (running well, not at gimpy VPC speed), or whatever. You can have your cake and eat it too.

  23. I may lack the requisite technical knowledge, but wouldn’t this not prevent the machines from running Windows, but rather would prevent them from booting directly into Windows–a good thing, since booting into Windows on startup isn’t exactly a security feature.

    Seems to me, though, that there wouldn’t be anything about this that would prevent windows from being run in a container inside OS X, though, is there? The real performance hit with VPC currently is code translation, which wouldn’t be an issue on intel macs.

  24. I’m really disappointed about this development. I think having the dual boot capability will convince a lot of disgruntled Windows users to try Mac. Yes, I know there will probably be hacks and workarounds, but they will not appeal to potential switchers.

    Not having this capability will delay Apple reaching critical mass.

  25. Dual booting will kill Apple

    After all why should a developer spend the money for a Mac OS X version of their software?

    “Aw just boot Windows like everyone else”

    Eventually Apple will be just selling software and iPods.

    a$$w1p3$

    w4tt? n07 733t 3n0ugh f@660t??

  26. Hopefully Apple has it’s own emulation planned.
    An emulation that would allow you to run Windows apps within a window in OS X without MS.
    That would drive 60% of the Windows users to Mac’s

    Apple would go from 4% of users to 60+% overnight!

  27. When Windows Vista comes out, I’ll get a copy and put it on my Homebrew Hal 9000. Why? Because there’s always something I can’t seem to find the software to do on my Mac.

    When the next version of OS X comes along I’ll put it on my iMac. Maybe I’ll get a PowerMac with dual core processors in it. But what I’d like to know is why the hell does it always have to be one or the other with you guys?

    If two different kinds of hammers get the job done, why force yourself to use only one.

  28. Anyone know what partition table format the new Macs use? If it is not the old DOS MBR format it might still not work with dual boot even once Vista is out and supports EFI.

  29. OpJ:

    I totally see where you are coming from, but it’s not that simple unfortunately. It is true that the applications would be talking to the CPU in the same language, but Applications spend most of their time executing functions that are found in the operating system. It is possible to set up a contained environment in which you can run the desired operating system (http://www.vmware.com/) – but such an approach is expensive and resource-intensive, since you end up loading up two operating systems simultaneously on your computer. It is also possible to run an environment that “remaps” calls to the other operating system to equivalent calls in the current operating system (http://www.winehq.com/) while avoiding the need to do any software emulation, but this is a really tricky process and doesn’t ever get you 100% compatibility. (Rosetta is sort of an inverse version of that – it catches calls to operating system libraries and runs them natively, and uses software emulation to translate the parts of the program that are dealing strictly with the CPU.)

    Because of the difficulties described above, dual-boot is pretty much the way to go.

    =)

  30. Wake up matrix3.
    No way in the world 60% of Windows users would switch overnite.. and it won’t be a matter of even 5 years. Cars had many advantages over horse drawn wagons but didn’t replace the mammals for a long time.

    And having the “open source” community write some hack to allow an intel based Mac to dual boot won’t make for significant new business for Apple either. Stop deluding yourselves about the wholesale collapse of the market for MS.

    Don’t get me wrong. I am a Macophile to my very (single) core. I want to see Apple succeed everywhere but I recognise that most people just want to write letters and track their income and play a few games. Most people use computers because they need to and the vast unwashed majority never look closely enough at the system or understand that the big box beside their knee IS the computer and not just the “Hard Drive”

    You want to see Apple really flourish? Keep healthy and stay away from pigeons, sparrows, turkeys, chickens and other poultry. Wash your hands frequently and encourage all the other Macintosh users to do the same… Avian Flu is probably the only thing that might really have a quick influence on the population of Windows users.

    Perhaps we could start a new campaign to help things along…. Lets all be supergenerous and give a Windows user a pet canary or budgie bird!!!!

    Perhaps a pet parrot as a gift to Bill Gates…..

  31. And also, everyone has a different opinion for what a car should be:

    America: a car which has to be maintained, but if done so will last 20 years.

    Japan: a car which does not have to be maintained, but will last 125,000-130,000 miles, or 12-15 years.

    Germany: Somewhere between America and Japan, but safer, too, and more “driver experience” than “driving experience” (america) or “driven experience” (japan)

    Macs seem to be a safe, driving/driver/driven experience, which will last a long time without maintainance.

    This magnet power chord thing I’m wary about, though. It seems like Apple is going to try to go for the “no maintainance” route, too, by trying to reduce dramatic liability (anything other than faulty insides), or in other words: be really careful concerning your LCDs

  32. The ELILO EFI Linux boot loader works with recent Linux kernels (which have EFI runtime support build in) so you should be able to dual boot OSX and a Linux of your choice.
    From within Liniux then a matter of using WINE for running Windows apps.
    I cannot afford an Intel Mac – feel free to donate me one and I will happily investigate if this is a viable way to run windows, or indeed if the ELILO boot loader will allow a cheat way to run windows ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  33. iMaki and twdldee have addressed the 32-bit vs 64-bit Mac on Intel question. I was amazed/appalled at this. The G5 was touted as 64-bit computing, woohoo. Doesn’t 32-bit Intel seem like a step backwards?
    I want 64-bit Mac on 64-bit Intel.
    In 1984, I had an 8-bit CPM Epson computer, and my friend chided me for not moving to IBM’s advanced 16-bit 8086 processor. But it worked great until I get restless for a Mac LCII in 1992, and moved on. This is year 2006, why are we still in 32-bit mode? Waaaaaahhhhh, I spilt my chocolate milk.
    MW=eyes, Mine eyes have seen the glory of the coming of Intel…

  34. RE: “Dual booting will kill Apple

    After all why should a developer spend the money for a Mac OS X version of their software?

    “Aw just boot Windows like everyone else””

    Dual booting will give the user the choice of operating systems. OSX vs. whatever flavor of Windows.

    Who wins in that scenario? Easy call; OSX wins.

    So then who develops for the winner? Any developer with half a brain.

    Who wants developers who have less than a full brain? Nobody, except those who are stuck with old Windows software and hardware.

    Translation; we win.

    It just amazes me that some of you think that in a head to head competition that Windows will win. Unless you think that Windows is actually better.

    Hey , some of us have to be wrong, and it’s you!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.