RealNetworks drops 21%, Napster plummets 30% on Yahoo music news

“Internet powerhouse Yahoo Inc. is introducing an online music subscription service that will enable consumers to download thousands of songs onto their portable MP3 players for $60 annually, undercutting the prices of the current industry leaders by more than 60 percent,” The Associated Press reports. “The Sunnyvale-based company planned to unveil ‘Yahoo Music Unlimited’ Wednesday in a direct challenge to similar subscription services offered by Real Networks Inc. and Napster Inc.”

“Yahoo is offering unlimited downloads from a library of 1 million songs for $6.99 per month or $60 for an annual subscription. That’s a sharp discount from Los Angeles-based Napster and Seattle-based Real Networks Inc., which both charge $14.95 per month, or just under $180 annually, for similar services,” AP reports. “By encouraging consumers to become song renters instead of song owners, Yahoo, Napster and Real Networks are pursuing a different sales approach from Apple Computer Inc.’s popular iTunes music store.”

At the opening of NASDAQ trading this morning, RealNetworks lost 21% and Napster shed 30%. Shares of Apple Computer are currently off 3.76%.

Full article here.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
J.P. Morgan: Yahoo music service ‘does little to break Apple’s tight grip’ on digital music market – May 11, 2005
Yahoo launches Napster To Go, Rhapsody To Go killer (takes aim at Apple’s iTunes Music Store?) – May 11, 2005

27 Comments

  1. I don’t want to rent my music and spend money that will just end up going up in smoke should I decide to cancel my subscription. I like the simple idea of iTunes buying a song and being able to keep it and never worry about it disappearing on me someday. We buy CD’s everyday and don’t make a big deal about it. A buck for a song or 10 bucks for a full album is a great deal with iTunes and besides you can burn your own CD. You can’t do that when you rent from these places. Unless of course you want to pay a dollar a song again!

  2. Right there with ya, John. I’ve said as much months ago when Napster & others started up their subscription services. In the words of Dana Carvey as Daddy Bush, “Not ga daaaaa”

  3. 60 bucks a year isn’t bad … that’s 600 bucks every ten years .. 6000 bucks every lifetime … plus about 25000 bucks for all the music that you can’t rent, can’t buy online, and end up buying elsewhere for premium prices since online music rental doesn’t get anyone squat that’s worth listening to.

  4. While it’s tough to see AAPL down over a buck in early trading, I know that it’s a temporary loss that will most likely be made up by Friday. Target price on AAPL is like $54, so I’m not concerned. If I owned Napster or Real stock – I would be concerned. Those are one trick pony shops that may not recover.

  5. We love Rob Glaser.

    R.G. is one of our most valued customers. He has a daily standing order of fifty dozen glazed doughnuts that are to be hand-delivered to his office. We were even told that he sometimes shares a few of them with his employees. Who knew?

    We sincerely hope that that Rob’s company, RealNetworks, doesn’t financially suffer because of Yahoo!’s recent foray into the digital download arena. That would be sad for us.

    We like Rob, we really do. We want him to have lots, and lots, and lots of money to be able to spend on our doughnuts. So what if he’s fat? He helps keep us in business, and really, deep down, that’s all we care about.

    Long live RealNetworks!

  6. This will perk up Apples ears towards possibly offering subscription services in the future if it does well.
    I love the fact that is just shows that Nappy and Real are milking the daylights out of people cost wise and I tip my fedora to Yahoo for bringing that to light…the stock drops say it all.

    iTunes will need a upgrade in a year or so, and if Yahooga proves people really want subscriptions, then I guess Apple will eventually add it to their mix, but not make a huge deal of it. But for the time being, I think Apple will sit pretty and wait and see what happens, all the while beefing up the movie/video section to stay with or above Sony, which is part of a record company itself. Apples advantage in this area is Quicktime and it appears they are utilizing it.

  7. The price is right, but what scares me isn’t that I might want to cancel a subscription…it’s that Yahoo/Real/Napster may decide to pull the plug on their end. Even if I wanted to keep a subscription, I couldn’t, and I’d lose all the songs I previously had access to. Does this disturb anybody else? They could justify it by saying “even though you have nothing to show for it, we don’t owe you anything…you RENTED that music”.

    At least when I buy a CD or download from iTMS, there’s a physical file that I can use for a long time.

  8. Subscriptions are a total waste of money.

    You might as well throw the money out of your window every month!

    What happens in 2 years time when you cancel your subscription?

    YOUR MUSIC LIBRARY GOES WITH IT!

  9. I’d never spend $60 per yer to rent music but I would to have the ability to get a full trial of an unlimited number of new songs/CD’s before going out and buying them.

  10. I was thinking that exact thing, Melanie. Especially now that the war has started amongst the subscription providers. There is more of a chance than ever that one or more of those services will simply go away. If you happen to be a subscriber to one of them, you’re pretty much screwed. Thanks for playing.

  11. I think Yahoo, with the combination of a la carte sales and subscription rental, could have a hit on their hands.

    Unlike Napster and Rhapsody, Yahoo can draw users who already enjoy other Yahoo services to the new music venture. If you already have a Yahoo account–and lots of people do–it’s a snap to sign up.

    I’ve downloaded the Yahoo Music Engine and checked out the service on my office PC. It looks very good–actually, surprisingly good.

    The Music Engine is a streamlined iTunes clone, which installed very easily, and so far is working seemlessly. Good quality, uninterrupted streams (so far), etc. Very strong for a beta release.

    I like sampling entire albums before I buy them. That $6.99 a month I pay Yahoo could save me $30 a month in ill-advised downloads.

    I can listen on Yahoo and buy on iTunes to keep my iPod fat and happy.

    I’ll keep this subscription until Apple offers a subscription option on iTunes.

  12. Dude’s, I buy tons of music from iTMS, but a $60 per year subscription for access to an entire catalog sounds like a good way to listen to a wide variety of music so that I can buy it off iTMS. You try it, then buy it. And, come to think of it, if the tracks are only 79 cents with a subscription, I would save some money. I’d give it a whirl if it were for Mac and wasn’t WMA.

  13. “With Apple stock dropping over 6% shows how vulnerable Apple is being tied to the one product – ipod and tunes.”

    Stockboy,

    Apple clearly isn’t a “one product” company. Real and Napster are. That’s why they are down a lot more than Apple.

    What is interesting to me on this move is the possible shift in attitude for the record companies. In an article posted sometime over the past week, there is a statement that the record companies like the subscription models better because the margins are better for them than the iTunes sales model.

    However, is this still true with the Yahoo deal? I don’t see how it can be, with the price so muuch lower than the others, unless Yahoo is willing to lose money (which I doubt).

    In the long run, anything that is a force to lower record company profiits from iTunes alternates is GOOD for Apple, especially if it drives some of the competitors out of business in a way that screws the competition’s customers.

  14. 6.99 is only an introductory price. Yahoo seem to be planning to take the subscription market by the balls and raise the prices to profitable levels once all the competitors have fallen by the wayside.

    The point that Yahoo have many other ventures tied to their service is a good one. With more services available they can increase their revenue stream by charging more for ads both on their existing pages and the ones associated with the music service.

    They probably don’t even need to make a profit with music sales or subscriptions. It’s all about the ad sales for these boys.

    Pretty smart business model. Napster and Real are in big trouble. Apple are okay cos they have the hardware tied to their own service.

  15. So if you started with Real, then switched to Napster, you’d lose all your subscription songs right? And then Yahoo comes along and undercuts everybody, so you have to switch and then find all of your subscription songs again?

    No thanks, I’m happy ripping cds, the occasional ITMS download, and the rare, but sometimes necessary, P2P option. Besides with all the “choices” these 3 services offer none of them work with my mac, or my iPod ….

  16. My observation that nobody makes money at $6 per month for a subscription service, and that once several million songs are held hostage Yahoo will raise the price finds some support:

    “We believe that after the beta, Yahoo! will raise pricing to between $10 and $15 per month,” Piper-Jaffry said.

    But maybe even $15 is low. What if subscription prices act like cable TV rates? $20 in 2006? $25 in 2007? Imagine having a few thousand “rented” songs in that scenario and being held hostage.

  17. Apple does make more money from ipods than itms, right?. And people realy like ipods over other players, right?. Then why not open ipods to the Napster like services around there?.

  18. How often and for how long at a time do these subscribers sit in front of their computers to listen to music? is it worth the subscription fees?

    OH, FIRST POST!
    WOO HOO!!!

  19. Have any of these music rental companies explicitly said how much money they pay to the artists ?

    I can’t imagine that many artists are getting rich on this sort of scheme.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.