Pink iPod knock-offs delivered by donkeys promote democracy in Afghanistan

“The employees of Voice for Humanity, in a fever of righteous idealism, traveled six hours on donkeys and horses through the remotest parts of the Afghanistan countryside. They were on a mission: to deliver what they thought was an invaluable literacy tool for Afghans. Pink for women, silver for men,” Fariba Nawa writes for GNN (Guerilla News Network). “They were custom digital audio players resembling the trendy iPod, made in China and filled with public service messages on topics including human rights, women’s rights, Afghanistan’s election process, and health.”

“The aid workers distributed 65,800 recorders, which cost $50 each, to remote villages and some of the most dangerous and volatile areas in the country. The staff of Voice for Humanity, a non-profit humanitarian aid agency that claims to be dedicated to developing literacy in the world, says it has trained tribal chiefs and other community leaders to listen to the recorders and then pass them on to individuals and families,” Nawa reports. “The pseudo-iPods were funded by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). The $8.3 million contract was granted to Kentucky-based Voice for Humanity, a small group run by two Lexington businessmen, to use its audio players to ‘promote democracy’ in advance of the 2004 Afghan presidential election.”

Nawa reports, “Critics say it was those connections that resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars going to an ineffective and laughable program of throwing trendy technology at serious international issues. ‘It shows how foolhardy people can be when they’re not thinking practically,’ said Patricia Omidian, an aid worker heading the American Friends Service Committee.”

Full article here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Too Hot!” for the heads up.]

MacDailyNews Take: American public service messages on Chinese iPod knock-offs for Afghans; ah, the wonders of globalization! If literacy is an issue, meaning that printed books wouldn’t work, couldn’t the American businessmen could have used real Apple iPods (shuffles) instead of buying Chinese knock-offs for $50 per unit? What Chinese iPod knock-off is actually worth $50 per unit? That’s $3.29 million total. Surely, Apple could have done at least as well as $50 per unit on an order for 65,800 iPod shuffles?

Advertisements:
• Apple’s brand new iPod Hi-Fi speaker system. Home stereo. Reinvented. Available now for $349 with free shipping.
• Apple’s new Mac mini. Intel Core, up to 4 times faster. Starting at just $599. Free shipping.
• MacBook Pro. The first Mac notebook built upon Intel Core Duo with iLife ’06, Front Row and built-in iSight. Starting at $1999. Free shipping.
• iMac. Twice as amazing — Intel Core Duo, iLife ’06, Front Row media experience, Apple Remote, built-in iSight. Starting at $1299. Free shipping.
• iPod Radio Remote. Listen to FM radio on your iPod and control everything with a convenient wired remote. Just $49.
• iPod. 15,000 songs. 25,000 photos. 150 hours of video. The new iPod. 30GB and 60GB models start at just $299. Free shipping.
• Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.

37 Comments

  1. I know this is a small issue, but have they considered these ‘petty issues’:

    A. Do the people who are getting these things actually HAVE ELECTRICITY?
    B. Do they own a COMPUTER to plug these things in and therefor able to put content on them?

    WTF use is an ‘ipod knockoff’ gonna be to someone living in a hovel, with no power, no computer or no internet access in the most dangerous and unstable parts of the country?

    Imagine getting one of these things, as soon as you get it and people find out your house will be raided, your family beaten up and the ‘ipod knockoff’ stolen and sold on the blackmarket for money to buy food.

  2. “I have to wonder: Do they have electricity to recharge these audio players?”

    Well, those aren’t just any regular donkeys…those are specially charged electrical donkeys! Its amazing what heroin will buy!

    Ferguson out.

  3. MDM … bad take … this is not about cheap knock off vs Apple iPod … it’s about a fool hearty plan that wastes tax payers dollars … I am sure the money could have been spent more wisely …

  4. > I have to wonder: Do they have electricity to recharge these audio players?

    No, they will put them in the cupboard with the cans they got and for which they have no can-openers…

    My guess is some schoolbooks would have been more intelligent if they want to do something for human and womens rights.

  5. Turd Ferguson said: “Well, those aren’t just any regular donkeys…those are specially charged electrical donkeys! Its amazing what heroin will buy!”

    To get six hours of use from one charged donkey is amazing.

  6. Afghanistan Banana Stand is the phrase for triggering a post-hypnotic suggestion in an “old” (well, 1970 or thereabouts) movie which, here in the UK at least, was called The Hot Rock with Robert Redford, George Segal, Zero Mostel and the guy who went on to play Rachel’s father in Friends.

    I challenge anyone to come up with a more bizarre piece of trivia for this thread…

  7. MDN….dont think you had your coffee.

    If shuffles were given out then maybe just maybe…not all the messages would have been played and the messages probably need to be played in sequence not in shuffle mode. You are not thinking.

    Radio would have been the better option.

  8. Schmutz! — There’s not a widespread hunger problem in Afghanistan (at the moment).. oppression and ignorance are the trouble.

    Halix — Literacy is a problem, so textbooks without teachers aren’t the best tool just now. As TFA points out, radio receivers would be more cost-effective, but I’ll bet you dollars to doughnuts that these MDN-maligned “knock-offs” have FM receivers built in. (as the sheep bleat out: “this is a feature without a market! an FM tuner is stupid! baaahahhhh!”)

  9. Anyone have a link to a picture of the music player in question? If it’s too close in appearance to an iPod, Apple needs to sue the US Gov’t (USAID is a federal agency, iirc) along with the Chinese manufacturer and (if they’re representing it as an iPod to the recipients) those distributing them.

  10. And…

    The MDN take is correct but misses two points, one of which has been mentioned here already:

    (1) Power to charge these? The Shuffle can go considerably longer between charges, no?

    (2) Is the cheap player HDD or flash based? If the former, that’s rather stupid: Afghanistan is rather rough, arid and dusty. A Shuffle is better suited to such conditions, not to mention easier to conceal (I imagine there are “bad guys” who would view with suspicion anyone carrying Western propaganda.

  11. “Yeah, you wonder what $50.00 would have bought in food.”

    Exactly, if they can’t read and don’t have computers any many don’t have electricity. What in Allah’s name are they going to do with an MP3 player. Unless it’s a propaganda tool filled with subliminal Pro-America chanting in hopes of brainwashing and assimilating the indigenous people, and comes with a lifetime supply of batteries, I see this as a bad idea.

  12. giofoto,

    MDN have had their coffee. You are the one not thinking. Don’t write about things you don’t understand. The iPod shuffle doesn’t just shuffle. You set up the tracks in iTunes in the order you like and play them straight through, not shuffled, on the iPod shuffle.

  13. How incredibly ignorant and overly simplistic to look at this story as just another Apple vs. “Knock-off” debate.

    Saying the money should rather be used for food: a legitimate argument.

    Saying that a poor not-for-profit agency is stupid for trying to save money by buying a cheaper product: you’re just being vindictive.

  14. iPod shuffle expert:

    Good to know…I have the nano not the shuffle. Thank you for the clarification.

    And when the battery runs out then what mr. expert? Pass out the accessory that charges on electrical outlets as well? not for free. It becomes disposable after 8 hrs? its a waste.

    I still stand…the Radio was the best option to propagate to the masses in the long run.

    Now go drink your coffee.

  15. wow, just how stupid can another feel group organization be?

    Secondly, why are my hard earned tax dollars being used to give some individual, living 2 steps above the stone age, an mp3 type player. If they have time to crank the charger and sit back and listen to this nonsense that no doubt has filled the player – they can go out and learn to read, farm their food and make a decent life for themselves.

    What a waste of my tax dollars.

    Someone ought to suggest this touchy feely organization have their collective heads examined.

    For those who traveled thrugh the mountains with donkeys and risked their lives – wow, are they stupid.

  16.  
    Relax, fellows. We’ve been there before. Consider Ben Franklin’s case, for example, when the Congress got up in arms over Ben’s accounting methods.

    Having been sent to Paris for the purpose of encouraging the King of France to fund our revolutionary activities against the English here in the Americas, Ben had to resort to the trickery of John Paul Jones to cause the King to fork over three million livres for Ben’s use. This act is amazing enough in its own right but there it is for us to still consider even to this day.

    Now here’s the Congressional rub: Ben spent two million livres of that three million kitty to purchase the weaponry deemed most useful for our revolution. The Congress, years later, demanded to know where the other million livres went. Now that was as good a question then as it is even to this day. Imagine it, the Congress challenging Ben Franklin that way!

    Well, Ben threw up his hands in his usual humorous style and said, “Why don’t you ask the French King?”

    Well, that is exactly what the Congress did. They sent a letter to the French king demanding to know what happened to the outstanding million livres. Imagine that, will you?

    The French king replied. He did. He said, essentially, “Here in France, we consider such a question as l’affaire du cabinet. Such matters are best left alone.”

    So it may be with today’s means of getting a difficult job done. An iPod, be it a knockoff or not, might beat the heck out of the means John Paine used to distribute his revolutionary message. History presented years from now might offer a very interesting comparison.

    Frankly, the technical aspects of the problem being described fascinates me. I’d be interested in learning how those knock-offs battery system works. Is there a hand cranked generator going along for the ride? How about the DRM involved with the knock-offs, will the other kind of guys be able to use them, too. Gotta think warfare here, my friends.

    Further, I doubt a U.S. Agency would openly circumvent a U.S. firm without being aware of the consequence. There’s more than whatever meets the eye here? Don’t bother asking?

    Now, if this report is true, then with the American appreciation of their iPods in mind, can you imagine what the Afghans might think of their knock-offs? Sure, they are like us in most ways, and there will always be some bad experiences such as those mentioned above no matter what the technology involved may be, but their society will work those matters out one way or another.

    I still can’t get over this matter of Ben Franklin. After all he had done to bring about our revolution, he still managed his humor when confronted by an irate Congress wishing to question his steadfast adherence to a strict moral, ethical code – within the context of the most revolutionary of feats.
     

  17. Hey, I got it! Why not give them iPod photos and have them loaded with pictures of people reading books and making electricity (like those solar dish fields in Albuquerque, New Mexico).

    That would be a very efficient way to communicate the Western world lifestyle!

  18. MDN, you’re raising the right topics, for sure. You’re showing Apple’s more strategic values. I don’t believe Apple wants to get into warfare, though. Maybe that’s the reason for the knockoffs.

    We’ve long known the iPod has strategic values largely untouched by society. Look for added uses and also users. All users might not be friendly and some I’ve heard sure do mouth off a lot, as in radically.

    Consider, if you will, both the stinger missile and the iPod.

    Is there a cost contrast? The cost of one stinger equals the cost of how many iPods?

    Can either be reused, time and again?

    Which would you be willing to give a friend, so that he/she might carry it about in a somewhat casual manner?

    If you gave one of each to friends to carry around with them, how would their wobble (gait) differ? (Hint: the gaits might compare to a Duke student’s while listening to music versus while cramming all puckered up as he/she walks to the next final exam.)

    When might the iPod be more useful than the stinger?

    Is the use of the iPod for such knock-off purposes kinda dopey? (Well, some might listen to the iTunes current top ten and feel a bit dopey!)

    I know, it’s not a fair contrast here but we could have some fun with the idea of contrasting, couldn’t we? Some are better at this than I am. I’d like to see more contrasts from others, if possible.
     

  19. It’s astonishing how many people make comments that are already explained in the article linked to.

    The article explains –
    How the units are powered – Solar & hand crank.
    Why Chinese units were used – So they don’t have American associations.
    Why it’s considered better than radio – The ability to rewind and hear parts again.
    How they’re not much like iPods – It tells of one being played to a gathering of 500 people.

    There are many other points mentioned in the article, not least being the wisdom, or otherwise, of the entire venture, but clicking on a link and reading the original article would appear to be more difficult than clicking on the reply button and making some comment that shows you’ve never read the article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.