Microsoft launches free beta of ‘Photoshop killer’ called ‘Acryllic’

“Microsoft has quietly launched the beta program for its new illustration, paint and image-editing tool codenamed Acrylic. It is aimed at graphics pros working in print, web, video and interactive media,” Grace Aquino writes for PC World. “According to Microsoft, Acrylic is based on Expression 3 (formerly from Creature House). It combines both pixel-based painting with raster- and vector-graphic editing… To run the beta, you need Windows XP Service Pack 2 installed on your computer.”

“The 77MB Acrylic beta is available as a free download [Windows-only] from Microsoft’s site, and expires October 2005,” Aquino reports. “More details, including a shipping date and support for Mac OS X, were not available.”

Full article here.

68 Comments

  1. Why does everyone think this is a Photoshop competitor? This app derived from Creature House Expression, which was first brought to the market many years ago by Fractal Design – you know, the people who brought Painter to the market. In effect, this app can be called Painter, but with vector strokes. I still use version 3, which I bought a few years ago. It’s really a nice app in its own way – with an interface that isn’t very Mac-like, although very functional and if you are openminded, you come to appreciate it.

    If you can forget that it is not Photoshop and not Illustrator – it doesn’t want to be – this is a nice app with which you can create beautiful artworks. I was sad when Microsoft bought up the company. Now I don’t know if this app has a future on the Macintosh. We need more apps like this one at reasonable prices. I bought this app around $200 or $250. Show me another app which offers painting/drawing in vector strokes, with ink, chalk, watercolor effects. There isn’t any out there that I know other than Illustrator. I really hope that Microsoft will bring a Mac version. Please, don’t judge this app because it’s now Microsoft, and don’t judge this app for not being a true Photoshop or Illustrator. It’s an app in its own right.

  2. Been there, done that. The program SUCKS. It’s a glorified Paint program that has the system requirements of a supercomputer to use. Typical MS bloatware. Why won’t they either finish Longhorn or fix XP first?

    I usually don’t do this, but the MW is “enough” as in I’ve had “enough” of Microsoft’s nonsense.

  3. If it comes from Microsoft and has the word “graphics” in it you can be assured that it is a complete and total peice of crap software. NOTHING MS EVER releases will ever be considered a “Photoshop “killer.

    BTW – I checked on their DL page and you must be running WinXP with SP2 for it to work properly. It is not compatible with Win2K. WTF!?!?!?!

  4. Greetings and Salutations,

    JadisOne I didn’t appreciate your comment! When I see you I’ll be sure to throw a pie in your face! And then I’ll slip a twenty dollar bill in your shirt pocket!!

  5. Yeh, like I’ll give up my AMAZING Adobe Creative Suite for a piece of BETA software from a company that cannot even make a decent OS, even though it has been trying since 1985.

    Can you imagine the offices of USA Today using Acrylic:

    “We’ve got to get this paper to press in 25 minutes, what’s the hold-up?”

    “Sorry boss, Acrylic keeps crashing every time we try to export a PDF. I think we need to buy the PDF export plugin, only $499 from Microsoft.”

    “But Steve Ballmer told me Acrylic was better than CS2, you mean to say I can’t create a PDF?”

    “No, not unless you…. oh wait, it’s crashed again. Can you call the press room and ask them if tomorrow is OK. Hopefully we’ll have Creative Suite 2 re-installed then. What do you want me to do with these copies of Acrylic?”

    “Well if you put the disks in an oven for a while then bend them, they make great ash trays.”

  6. so MDN reports earlier on napster/erricson teaming up…(yeah yeah..i can see the relation to apple there) and now this….isn’t photoshop made for PCs too?!?! so WHY is this mac news….this isn’t competing directly with macs since macs compete anyway with photoshop for XP……what the world….

  7. insult billy and get paid….

    i hate you billy!!! and i hate everything you make!!

    MW wrong…everything u do is wrong ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />

  8. I actually loved the app ‘Expression’ (of which Acrylic was morphed from) but the development was halted as soon as M$ took over… It was way ahead of it’s time – in the day.

    I sometimes use it (still), but Illustrator had just gotten so much better…

  9. From the company that can’t even design a decent OS…yet another “bought” product that they have ruined. Bet everyone at Adobe is rolling on the floor laughing. All these announcements from Microsoft about what they are “doing” is bad for productivity—they’re making everyone lose time with all the laughter. Or putting them all to sleep; take your pick. The ratio of failed, money-losing products to successful products is getting larger. Everyone waiting for Shorthorn has got to be discourage at how Microsoft waste time and energy on it’s attempts to conquor the rest of the electronic world.

  10. If this is intended to compete with Adobe, I thiink that’s GREAT! They need competition to frive the industry forward. Plus, MS pissing on Adobe can only be a good thing for Adobe’s relatonship with Apple.

    If it isn’t a competitor to Adobe, then that’s fine too. More products, more options.

  11. Hello, my name is Johny Habisco, I’m the lead developer of Acrylic.

    I say this on behalf of my remote staff of 200 programmers in Bangdali India….BITE ME!!!

  12. I liked the app Expression too — there was a Mac version. Actually you could download Expression for Mac from MS’s website until they changed the name to Acrylic.

    It is NOT a Photoshop-type program (unless MS has added a lot of junk to it). It was a really nice vector-based paint program. After Expression came out, Illustrator copied their functionality, although I think Expression’s features were still more robust. With Illustrator Adobe just tacked on the basic functionality of Expression.

    I’ve never had any problems with it being processor-intensive as JadisOne claims. I used it on a Pentium III around 1988-1990, and it worked fine. More recently I installed the Expression 3.3 beta for OS X, and it works like a charm (although I rarely use it) … although the interface is so clunky it’s a bit of a turn-off.

  13. Embrace the future.

    The real IT world knows that this is one of the killer applications that MS is preparing to infiltrate the photoarts market that Apple has previously dominated. This, in conjunction with .Net will change e-commerce and real commerce in ways that most can never fathom.

    This is a pre-emptive volley by MS to destroy the previous and last remaining stronghold that Apple holds in graphic arts field.

    Consider this as “war declared.”

    ©

  14. Photoshop killer hahaha. Just that they are marketing it as such is a joke. BTW, note to Microsoft, right now you need fewer enemies, not more. Please please piss off Adobe.

    Expression was kinda a cool concept, but man look at one of those drawings in keyline view and the problem becomes apparent. They get too complex. If you need to paint, use Photoshop, or better yet, Painter. This tool violates a design axiom, ‘just because you can, doesnt mean you should’. Can you do painted style graphics in vector, sure, but doesnt mean you should.

    That Microsoft is now selling this just makes it even more of a bad idea.

  15. Get a life Sputnik!

    The real IT world knows that this is one of the killer applications that MS is preparing to infiltrate the photoarts market that Apple has previously dominated. This, in conjunction with .Net will change e-commerce and real commerce in ways that most can never fathom.

    The real IT world is full of computerized bureaucrats that have an ill-perception that almost follows suit to that of unknowledgable consumers. .Net will never reach the status quo (or market penetration) of Java, since .Net is not cross-platform (and Mono/dotGNU don’t count). The world wants open standards and Microsoft is failing to deliver (proprietary XML file formats for Office 12 as a prime example of that failure).

    This is a pre-emptive volley by MS to destroy the previous and last remaining stronghold that Apple holds in graphic arts field.

    Hmmm… remaining? Apple has nearly 80% of the graphics and desktop publishing markets. Over half of Adobe’s revenue from Photoshop comes from Mac customers. There’s no doubt that Microsoft will attempt to chip away at Adobe’s market dominance in the digital document creation/collaboration world, but hopefully the Microsofties (such as M$ worshiping yourself) will be outnumbered by the rest of us who know better!

  16. I see really stupid comments. Guys, who wants you to ditch your Photoshop for a beta software? Is it prohibited for Microsoft to launch beta versions of their software, while it is allowed, and even recommended, for anybody else ?

    Expression is very good, but I’m afraid Acrylic won’t be that good. But who knows, it’s just a beta we’ve seen (but a tester said it is in reality an alpha version, a first alpha version).

  17. Sputnik:

    Real IT shops like to have support for software on their desktops and predictable product release timetables:

    http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=fh;[ln];lifecycle

    Microsoft is throwing their own support organization into exception mode because they can’t meet release dates – Windows XP will have to be supported until 2009 because they couldn’t ship LongDump on time.

    Note on XP: “Mainstream support will end 2 years after the next version of this product is launched. Extended support will end 5 years after Mainstream support ends.”

    Real IT shops like vendors that can deliver on their promises, or they go somewhere else for products.

  18. Acrylic is a vector drawing/painting program in competition with Illustrator/Painter/Freehand/Xara…if it is ever actually developed past the Beta version.

    Why Microsoft made it (it was being developed by the same people that created Expression) one has to wonder.

    The interface on Acrylic and Expression are hard to work with.
    I keep trying to use it…but after a bit I always go back to Illustrator for my vector illustration work.

    “Microsoft goes head-to-head with Photoshop”
    PCAdvisor is the idiot here – I bet they never even tried it out.

    Expression was interesting when it came out – but the files it makes are HUGE and then Illustrator tacked on what Expression can do…so who needs it?

    The people at Adobe are having a nice chuckle over this thing.

  19. It’s a vector drawing/paint app with some pixel-based features. It’s NOT a Photoshop killer! It was a nice app for the money when it was Expression – although, yes, with an interface that needed a polish.

    If everything is compared to Photoshop, by people who live and dream Photoshop, yeah these people will be disappointed and run as far away as possible. But I like the motto: An app for everyone. Choice is good. Yet, there isn’t any choice when it comes to vector-based paint/drawing apps. Where are the graphic apps for the Mac, other than Illustrator and Photoshop? Not everybody is an industry artist, some are just artists or creative people who don’t need all the functions (or even the price) of Illustrator, or Photoshop. Or some have the money and buy Painter – although I liked Painter better when is was Fractal Design/Meta Creations. There are many people out there who can do amazing things with Expression. Look around on the web.

    Each app has its positive and negative sides, but most people just talk foul when it’s MS or not an Adobe app. Come on guys, not everybody has to be a Photoshop or Illustrator person. I was a paid customer for Expression and want a Mac version of Acrylic. There needs to be choice!

  20. Expression was one of my most favorite tools for doing certain vector paint functions. It was underappreciated by the graphics community because it was a one trick pony. But it did it’s trick extremely well. MicroSuck should roast in Hell.

  21. Acrylic is just another example of Microsoft having totally and utterly lost its way…

    M$ aims to dominate in every type of software…but its products are now such junk that its becoming difficult to find to see how they will dominate in any area of software in the future.

  22. “Expression was one of my most favorite tools for doing certain vector paint functions. It was underappreciated by the graphics community because it was a one trick pony. But it did it’s trick extremely well. MicroSuck should roast in Hell.”

    Therein lies the irony. Microsoft is once again venturing into an arena where they have no idea what they are doing. They are trying to stick their fingers in EVERY piece of pie in an attempt to dominate that market. They do this by intimidating other companies and by decreeing things as standards. Yet everything they create is so blatantly mediocre or just downright bad.

    I hope they continue to stick their fingers in more pies. This will just aid in their eventual downfall as they try to be all things to all people.

  23. I’m not familiar with the app and I’m willing to believe it sucks, but I do think Adobe could use a little competition. The CS package is lousy, to be quite honest. Unstable and WAY too pricey. If the MS package could run for more than hour without crashing (unlike CS) I’d be quite interested in learning more about it.

  24. just an opening shot (very mild) in a MS war against the Mac.

    Even though Adobe has increased its support for Windows apps in recent years, they are still a prime Mac ally.

  25. Now is a good time for MS to be having a go at this.

    Adobe is really letting Photoshop in particular, other CS apps to a lesser extent, languish in a cloud of marketing hooplah instead of actually pushing the boundaries with their apps. Competition is good, as long as MS doesn’t come out on top!

    But the entire CS thing screams of marketing bullshit as opposed to real product innovation. Adobe needs a kick in the ass. I for one hope that MS provides a good stern one, in this case.

  26. As I consider myself a “graphics professional”, I’m obviously going to rush out and buy the “Photoshop killer” ‘Acryllic’ (and a PC to run it on), so who wants to buy my suite of Adobe Photoshop/Illustrator programs and my now defunct 17″ Powerbook and G4 tower?

    No one?

    Let me guess? You’re all about to do the same thing, aren’t you?

  27. Microsoft – “photoshop killer”…

    Having used photoshop for the last 12 years since version 2, I have only one word to say…

    LLLLLLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLL!!!!!!!!!

  28. The problem with “graphics” programs like this is the poor guy who has to print whatever is designed with this. I have worked in printing and it sucks to get files from people in formats like Microsoft Word or whatever. You cannot publish things from non-standard programs like that very well. They think that since they got a few copies to print with the laser printer that you can publish the same with a real printing press. Most people don’t understand what goes into printing something (and that includes alot of graphic designers).

  29. anyone here of y’all genious critics ever worked with Expession at all? Well, I did and it has some very unique features – esp. when you work with an intous or the like. Of course it’s not a PS killer, thats bullshite, but the app really rules in some areas.

  30. This is a Photoshop killer like MS Publisher is a QuarkXPress killer.

    I wonder if, with Acrylic, I can calculate a new channel by excluding 40% of the Cyan channel from 20% of the Black channel, making the new channel a spot color from the Toyo catalog and then save the file as a DCS EPS?

  31. “I used it on a Pentium III around 1988-1990, and it worked fine.”

    Apparently, your time machine worked fine, too. The Pentium III wasn’t released until 1999. The original Pentium wasn’t even around in 1988-1990.

  32. Wow. This was a great opportunity for an amazing MDN editorial.

    So, I’ll do it:

    This is a wake-up call to Adobe that Microsoft is not your friend, only a blood thirsty soulless company who tries to get every dollar from their “partners” as they can.

    Adobe, after the past 5 years of reluctant support of the Mac, maybe it is time to think a little long term and start propping up competitors to Microsoft. You are only help fund their war chest against your products.

    Let’s see some Mac-only products, or Mac products which have more features than the PC version. If any company can do this type of thing and have a business case for it, it’s Adobe. 50% of your customers are Mac people, and it is a strategic investment against a well funded and money thirsty competitor.

  33. Its like Publisher, total crap. Give a pre-press guy a disc made in Publisher with its special format & he’ll say F*ck its .pub nothing works with this. Change it using Acrobat & Distiller then fix it up. Time wasting MS crap with its special file formats. People will use this as Photoshop then wonder why a printer will throw them out the door with a foot up their ass.

  34. I’m a graphic arts pro and trainer — been doing it for 25 years.

    I just downloaded the Acrylic beta on my PC. This is not a ‘PhotoShop killer’. Or a PhotoShop Elements killer. This is not even a PaintShop Pro killer. It MAY be a MacPaint killer, but I’d have to find my old Mac 128K to check that first.

    Rather, this is a crude, thumb-fisted combo vector/raster combo program, similar in concept to Canvas (although not nearly as good — and we all know just ow well CANVAS is selling …).

    The UI is hilarious and the screen draw (even with my 256MB ATO graphics card) is painfully slow.

    If MS is stupid enough to release this as a ‘pro’ graphics application, it will be laughed out of the market in a month.

  35. Typical M$. Turn everything they touch into Fertilizer!

    Looked around the E3 download, but felt dirty. I can’t shake it, it’s now damaged goods.

    Needed to just trash this app.

    Next thing I know, I ‘ve got a kernel panic!
    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”angry” style=”border:0;” />

  36. The only way this will end up in wide distribution is if they keep giving it away for free and do a Netscape on Adobe. And even then it won’t end the same way. Photoshop is the center of the graphics world (along with Illustrator).

    This is simply Microsoft firing a shot over Adobe’s bow because of the Macromedia buyout.

    Imagine, Acrylic and their PDF replacement taking on Photoshop and Acrobat! That’s like Pewee Herman and Olive Oyle taking on The Rock and the Governator!

  37. rich b:

    amen brother. I’ve spent the last 4 days pulling 72dpi bitmaps out of Word documents for a screen print. Most people know squat about printing, and even less about design…

  38. It mystifies me why MS needs to get there noses into everything that is going on in some half assed, half backed way, while they really should be taking all the resources they can muster, which is a hell of a lot, and build a new OS. Or get out of the OS business altogether. I wonder where OS2 would be today if it hadn’t of been buried.

  39. The whole point of this app is that MS is creating a mono-culture of software for those enterprises (such as where I work, Queensland Rail) that have IT departments which insist on locking down the desktop with a single platform philosophy.
    Slowly but surely they are removing every piece of 3rd party software from the ‘approved software’ list in order to ensure ‘platform stability and security’.
    Our IT gurus have succeeded in killing off Macs in QR, which was particularly painful for our Graphic Services department, previously a Mac only shop (as you’d expect) making their productivity crash through the floor. As a consequence, this killed off Graphic Services and outsourcing all our DTP and EP – ironically to Mac only shops.
    Now please excuse me while I go bash my head against my desk repeatedly until the pain stops, or I pass out.

  40. Embrace your ass Sputnik!! “The real IT world knows that this is one of the killer applications that MS is preparing to infiltrate the photoarts market that Apple has previously dominated.” Yeah right, the same goes for MS BOB, killer app!!! .NET will be just as popular as MS BOB!!!! MicroS@#t will also introduce “ Color Sink” software embedded within LongYawn to battle Apple’s dominance in graphic reproduction industry too. Just you wait and see in 2007 or may be 2009 or may be 2013!!!! Long live Bill Gates and Steve Ballmer ( what changed? Apple runs on Intel? What change? My IQ is still the same, about 35. I still used to room with Bill and that made me the richest used car salesman in the world!! What changed?) so Windows hoes like you can SUCK UP !!!!

  41. “The real game is Adobe´s pdf files.”

    Yes, that’s right Queeezie! It’s all about Adobe’s pdf and Microsoft’s pdf like file format. I only hope Microsoft can kick Adobe in the A$$ enough bring down the price of PhotoShop! Adobe is the big monopoly in this arena and we need more competitive pricing! And please don’t get me started on their whole *$#%@*# “Activation” scheme!! BOGUS, completely BOGUS. Too much power!

  42. Dennis: “Apparently, your time machine worked fine, too. The Pentium III wasn’t released until 1999. The original Pentium wasn’t even around in 1988-1990.”

    You’re right. I mistyped. I meant 1998-1999.

  43. It’s amazing to see how the windows fans even bother to comment or even come here. What is it with this war between mac and pc anyway? I don’t get it. Is there a playstation vs xbox site somewhere? Or do houswives slag eachother off because they don’t have the same brand washing machine. Personaly i have a Teac TV and it picks up all the channels as good as my friends Sanyo TV. I mean what’s the problem. I don’t see why we can’t all have one of each (computers). Technologies pretty cheap these days.

    Mac user in a Windows world.

  44. From the MS website:
    “To download the Microsoft codename Acrylic (Beta) product, you are required to sign in with a Microsoft .NET Passport and complete the Limited Acrylic Announcements registration form.”

    Um, yeah right. What? No urine sample, brain and retinal scan, and all of my bank account numbers? “All in good time,” whispers Uncle Bill.

  45. MS Word killed WordPerfect and MS Excel killed Lotus 1-2-3, by developing two versions of WinAPI. One bug free version for MS and one full of memory leaks version for the competitors.

    MS PowerPoint was going nowhere, so they bundle it with Word and Excel to kill Adobe Persuasion.

    MS Access was bloated and useless, so again they bundle it with office to kill DBIII. FoxPro was too good to be beaten, so MS bought it and threw it in the trash.

    MS Outlook was a joke. So, it was bundled with Windows OS to kill Eudora.

    MS Internet Explorer was another software they could not get people to use even for free. So, it became an “essential” part of Windows OS.

    Visio…. They bundled it with Office. It just need few more years to kill Illustrator (I know the functionality of Visio is nowhere close to Illustrator, but MS only had it few years and look at other programs. MS has successfully killed its competitor with less capable programs, e.g. PowerPoint).

    Now they are setting stage for Photoshop. It will MS take a while to achieve their goal, but they will keep on working on it until either they succeed or until they go out of business.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.