Apple loses: Apple v. Beatles to be heard in Britain

“Apple Computer on Tuesday lost a British High Court bid to have a legal case brought by the management company of the legendary Beatles band moved from the United Kingdom to the United States,” Reuters reports.

“A London High Court judge on Tuesday struck down Apple’s request to have the case heard by California courts. The iPod maker had argued that because the original agreement between the two companies was struck in that state, it was the proper place for the hearing,” Reuters reports. “Launched a year ago, iTunes has given hope to weary music executives looking for an industry-backed online music store capable of derailing free file-sharing networks such as WinMX and Kazaa.”

Full article here.

33 Comments

  1. This is no big deal – though everyone in the media is trying to make it sound like it is. Apple Records could not possibly be confused with the iPod or the iTunes music store, especially since they are not actively selling music anymore. Regardless of what Apple Computer signed off on the last time an agreement was reached, this is just a pathetic attempt by the Beatles clan to extort some money. And in the worst case scenario, that’s all that would happen.

  2. The Brits are going to stick em.
    How much could it possibly cost to buy Apple records? Or better yet, the Beatles catalogue. I hear it’s valued at around 1 Billion. Apple could pay cash and then offer the Beatles on iTunes exclusively.

  3. This is no big deal. Actually it is very good indeed. Now there is a judge who owns a iPod. She knows what to do here and how to end this stupid lawsuit thing once and for all.

  4. or something like that with typos

    This is actually a very good news indeed ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
    After this we will see iTMS Europe and hopefully this year ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  5. I think it is sad when an individual or company thinks that it deserves some special consideration just for existing. The ironic part is that Apple Corp is suing Apple computer for being in the music business – Apple Corp hasn’t been in the music business for a very long time.

  6. Just because the trial will be in London doesn’t mean a loss. Perhaps it gives the Beatle Barons a home-court advantage, but they still have to make their case.

  7. One guy, I wonder if the judge knows about the Russian site, allmymp3.com? They have all the Beatles stuff for download, and there’s nothing Apple Corps can do about it.

  8. you have to remember that this is not paul and ringo. they do not own Apple Corps. Also – apple corps do not own the rights to the Beatles Catalogue, Sony and Michael jacson each have a 50% share in it. Besides the fact that Apple Corps has a legitmate argument. As if you can just cast aside the law by saying that Apple Corps is dead. so what? they signed a contract, and apple computer broke it. it’s a big deal, and apple computer will lose.

  9. If (and when) Apple Computer Incorporated looses this law suit… They end up paying something. When it is in Europe they will have to pay reasonable amount of cash. That is it. Nothing else. That will be few million �uros that Apple can afford easily and then the whole thing will be gone for ever!
    In the USA this could take years and years without any result and cost billions and take years and years and more years. Did I mention billions?
    This is very good news for the Apple Computer Incorporated indeed. Okay they have to fly First Class to London few times. That is not so bad?

  10. I have to fly only Business Class to San Francisco and Apple WWDC 2004.
    Then again there will be SF Pride too… ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  11. Do You have your ticket to the WWDC?
    It will be Great! Stevenote with all of those Gthings! You will find your G-spot in no time ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  12. Dave, ya think???

    How can Apple Corps be worth 1 billion if they don’t own any Beatles music? What do they own? Apparently, not much since they are dead…(According to ppl on this site)

    Whatever the outcome be, Apple Computer has the money to pay for it and finally put an end on it. It’s not like the average citizen knows about this and is thinking about NOT buying an iPod and going to ITMS. This won’t stop any of the momentum and probably won’t even be a blip on the radar.

    At least, unless the media makes it look like a bigger deal than it really is.

  13. “How can Apple Corps be worth 1 billion if they don’t own any Beatles music?”

    I was referring to the catalogue owned by Jacko and Sony as was pointed out by another poster. It’s been said to be worth about 1 billion. And Michael’s probably going to have to sell sometime soon.

  14. why in the world would michael jackson sell his stake in the beatles music? it’s the only thing keeping him going! the beatles bring jackson an estimated 150 million bucks in profit each year. how else could he afford neverland?

  15. Michael is not going to sell anything. He does not need to do it.
    Dave H
    You bet!
    I reserved my trip to WWDC today.
    It is a combination of Stevenote, WWDC, SF Pride ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
    I haven’t been drinking coffee.. more or less real beer (Karhu)
    Oh boy I can’t wait ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  16. Precisely what is Apple Corp’s beef, what would be Apple’s likely defense strategy, and what are the odds of a successful resolution for Apple Computer Co.?

  17. Re – quote “this could be big trouble my friends”

    All apple has to do is use the same logo and call themselves ‘Mac’ instead of ‘Apple’.

    Therefore no damage to image or PR – End of story!

    PS – Im a marketing/brand director at Saaatchi & Saatchi

  18. I live in the UK, and Apple Corps (UK) was soley setup by the Beatles many years ago as a company that brings in the cash from the Beatles royalties (almost like a money laundering service as it were).

    It was purely setup to make sure the Beatles got every penny of royalties and to invest their money that they made from selling singles/albums.

    As the previous comments quote – Apple Corps (UK) produces no product for the music industry and you can question as to whether they are now anywhere associated with the music industry at all in this modern age.

    My personal view is that it is purely a money making lawsuit for Apple Corps UK) and you must remember that this is probably one of the last ‘inherited mistakes’ that Steve Jobs has to deal with which was signed by Apple’s previous CEO before Steve Jobs came back to Apple.

    If Apple is going to lose lawsuit – then they should turn around the negitive PR and launch/announce a new name and an updated brand identity BEFORE it goes to court. This would totally get rid of any bad PR for Apple.

  19. Apple Corps still is in the business of selling music. They just released a remix of “Let It Be” not long ago (pretty good too), and of course the 3 anthology albums were on the Apple label. Can Apple really beat Apple in court?

  20. Apple Corp. owns all the original Beatle RECORDINGS–this is where they still gain revenue–having said that–Apple Corp should still lose because Apple Computer is NOT acting as a record label, but as a means to distribute the music (ala a record store)..but i agree, Apple could write a check to skirt this whole issue. Steve may be playing chicken w/ apple corp imo

  21. I remember in all of those old westerns. When a horse got a broken leg, the cowboy pulls his six shooter and shoo… the horse, ending it’s suffering.

    Why don’t Apple Computers or some else, do the same with this guys (or with SCO Unix, for that matter too). When was the last time the Beatles went to a recording studio? All they want is money. Preserving their rights as artist is one thing, but Apple Computers is not in the business of making music, they are just providing a service to support a product they make and sell, the iPod. Also there is no way that someone is going to mistake Apple Computers with Apple Corps or whatever the heck these old guys call themselves!

    Steve Jobs, pull out your checkbook and put this guys out of their misery!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.