As artificial intelligence models evolve at breakneck speed, the battle for conversational supremacy intensifies. In this head-to-head showdown, we pit OpenAI’s latest powerhouse, ChatGPT-5.1, against xAI’s bold challenger, Grok 4.1—testing them across nine diverse prompts spanning reasoning, creativity, coding, and emotional depth. The results? Elon Musk’s Grok doesn’t just compete; it dominates with sharper wit, deeper empathy, and a distinctly human edge.
Amanda Caswell for Tom’s Guide:
I couldn’t wait to see how ChatGPT-5.1 compares to Grok 4.1. The following is a result of a nine-round faceoff between the two popular chatbots. What I noticed first was that both models are exceptionally capable, but they shine in very different ways, and the differences say a lot about how each approaches reasoning, communication and personality…
After running nine tests, Grok 4.1 is declared the winner. It thrives where tone, subtext and interpretation matter as much as the answer itself. It is sharper than ChatGPT-5.1 with emotional framing, bolder with creativity and more willing to point out the obscure and interesting… ChatGPT excels when brevity matters but it’s clear that Grok 4.1 is the more “human” of the two chatbots. Grok is honest and smart, with a personality that ChatGPT just doesn’t have.
MacDailyNews Take: Caswell even gifted ChatGPT with a “win” in one category, code generation, even though both generated the proper code, but Grok offered more, adding “inline comments explaining the expansion logic and a brief comparison to other algorithms,” which Caswell marked off as “too verbose and not necessarily needed.” 🙄 In a fair world, in which we unfortunately do not live, that’s a tie, at worst. For being more explanatory, Grok should’ve won that category, too.
The amount of free publicity and digital ink dedicated to OpenAI’s inferior ChatGPT vs. the clearly superior Grok reminds us of the bad old days when so-called “tech” publications excreted endless reams focused on Microsoft’s shiteous Windows while virtually ignoring Apple’s peerless Macintosh.
Please help support MacDailyNews — and enjoy subscriber-only articles, comments, chat, and more — by subscribing to our Substack: macdailynews.substack.com. Thank you!
Support MacDailyNews at no extra cost to you by using this link to shop at Amazon.
I don’t care how good it is. Supporting anything in which Elon Musk is involved is nauseating. No reason to make that neofascist, white supremacist any richer.
… then, reaching down to grab a knife he cleanly cut off his own nose to spite his face.
Cry more you nazi bitch. Cry more
The thing that I notice most about “sensitive” people, is that they are always giving the conclusion (neofascist, white supremacist, etc), but never give the actual argument. They just “feel” that a person is bad, so they mindlessly shower offensive labels on them. Sorry, but this modus doesn’t work for thinkers.
Well Bud,
I’m not a sensitive person rather, I’m retired academic, and at times I occasionally shine a flashlight for intentionally or unintentionally myopic people like yourself.
Now I don’t have too far with Uncle Elon to find a bit of support for far right organisations.
Now I’m a pretty easy going bloke who takes the view that French woman Marine le Pen has done a half way decent in cleaning up the French National rally party. Not perfect, but she denounced Jewish holocaust deniers and whilst there are elements still in the party she’s had a good go at it.
Not so for Germany’s AfD party. They deny what happened to the Jews during WWII, minimise Germany’s involvement in the said act etc, etc, ad nauseum. Now that’s just one of their views.
And then there’s Uncle Elon, intervening in German politics and supporting a Neo Nazi political party that is one of the most far right wing parliamentary organisations in Europe.
There you go Bud, maybe you might want to do some research before you come out with comments that aren’t based on hard evidence. In fact it took almost no time at all to find this out.
Academics are generally communists. You fit the description.
Elon Musk saved free speech. That’s not “far right;” that was actually a tenet of liberals until a few decades ago. It is the American way.
Your fascist friends on the left were trying to destroy our first amendment rights.
Slander the AfD all you want but they are the only ones trying to end the third-world invasion of Germany.
And, calling Elon a Neo Nazi supporter tells me that you are a full blown moron.
You are the one lacking “hard evidence.” Do the world a favor and take a long walk off of a short pier.
Sounds like MAGA to me. That’s what they do. If you’re not far right, you’re called either a socialist or a communist.
Pretty stupid.
If the shoe fits…
You lefties did just elect a communist to be mayor of New York. And there are a couple more around the country that may win.
There is no denying that the left has embraced socialism/communism.
Save us your gaslighting.
Jeez, why can’t you at least dump the ideological the language for at least one sentence. With that in mind I have no respect for people on the left, centre or right who express their feelings in such an insulting manner. And believe you me it’s just not the right side of politics.
By the gods what happened to a degree of civility but then again at a political level it doesn’t exist as well so what should I expect.But hey I got you all out of the woodwork to show people what you’re really like. Suckered big time!
You leftards have been rioting, looting, harboring criminals and murdering in the apparent goal of destroying our country. And you want us to tone down the rhetoric?!
Get bent, commie!
And for a piece of accuracy I didn’t even vote in New York because I’m an Australian where we have manners and we don’t go around shooting people on a daily basis and we at least try to treat people with a bit of respect. FYI this site has gone hill since the early 2000s and that’s a shame. And I’ve witnessed the whole sorry mess. Sigh!