Apple iPad trademark case in Shanghai suspended; Proview injunction rejected

“A local court has rejected an effort by a Chinese company to stop Apple from selling its popular iPad here amid a trademark dispute over who owns the rights to the iPad name,” David Barboza reports for The New York Times. “The Shanghai Pudong New Area People’s Court released a statement on its Web site Thursday saying that it would not rule because a related trademark court case between the two companies was pending in Guangdong Province, in southern China.”

“An Apple spokeswoman confirmed the court decision and said the company would continue to challenge the position of the Chinese company, Proview International, which claims to own the trademark rights to the iPad name in mainland China,” Barboza reports. “‘Proview’s injunction request was rejected,’ Carolyn Wu, the Apple spokeswoman, said in a telephone interview Thursday. ‘The court granted Apple’s request to suspend the case.’ Apple insists that one of its subsidiaries acquired the rights to the iPad name in China from the Chinese company several years before the tablet computer was released.”

Barboza reports, “Shanghai was the Chinese company’s first major test of whether it could disrupt Apple’s selling apparatus in China.”

Read more in the full article here.

Related articles:
Proview sues Apple in the US, mass hilarity ensues – February 24, 2012
Proview files lawsuit in California against Apple over iPad trademark – February 24, 2012
Chinese court says Apple can continue selling iPads in Shanghai – February 23, 2012


  1. Am I the only one hoping that this bullsh*t doesn’t just end with Proview losing their suit, but being punished in some way, if not by the courts then by the markets? This suit is clearly a joke and similar suits need to be strongly discouraged.


    1. Yeah win the case, then equalize their debts with the involved parties, then have Apple buy that defunct company for 10c, then make it Apple’s main asian distributor. 🙂

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.