HP TouchPad hits Australia with a resounding ‘meh’

“HP unveiled its new webOS-powered TouchPad tablet to the Australian media [yesterday] morning, and it was met with a resounding “meh,'” Adam Turner reports for The Sydney Morning Herald.

“Anthony McMahon, vice president of HP webOS, took to the stage to sell the TouchPad’s virtues – but what we saw was yet another also-ran,” Turner reports. “The TouchPad has a Snapdragon dual-core 1.2GHz processor and 1GB of RAM under the bonnet, but you wouldn’t know it based on the sluggish hands-on performance… The TouchPad’s menus are slow to rotate, it’s sometimes slow to respond to touches and the browsing experience falls short of Mobile Safari and the Honeycomb browser.”

“McMahon kept throwing around the word ‘unique’ but could offer very little to back it up. Things didn’t turn ugly, but McMahon copped a few brutally honest questions such as a straight out ‘why would I buy one?'” Turner reports. “‘The way you interact with the device is unique,’ we were told, although we didn’t see anything ground-breaking.”

Advertisement: Limited Time: Students, Parents and Faculty save up to $200 on a new Mac.

Turner reports, “It’s hard to find a reason to get excited about the TouchPad… With no killer feature to capture the imagination, HP’s TouchPad will have a tough job winning people away from the competition.”

ull article here.

MacDailyNews Take:
HP descent

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “macca” for the heads up.]

Related articles:
HP bumps Rubinstein from webOS lead after TouchPad launch failure – July 11, 2011
Rubinstein addresses poor HP TouchPad reviews, compares webOS to Apple’s early Mac OS X – July 5, 2011
HP fiddles while Apple innovates – July 10, 2011
Rubinstein addresses poor HP TouchPad reviews, compares webOS to Apple’s early Mac OS X – July 5, 2011
HP TouchPad simply cannot compete with Apple’s iPad 2 – July 5, 2011
Pogue reviews HP TouchPad: ‘Doesn’t come close’ to Apple’s iPad – June 30, 2011
Mossberg: HP TouchPad ‘simply no match’ for Apple iPad 2 – June 30, 2011

26 Comments

  1. Greetings, I understand that this is “Mac Daily” an Apple favored website. I used the iPad1 for a year and iPad2 for two months until I purchased the Touchpad on July 1st. At first there were a lot of negative reviews but it seems things are somewhat turning the tables with the Touchpad. I do miss the rear camera and the app selection when I had the iPad2 but I would not underestimate the HP Touchpad. It has a lot of features the iPad2 cannot do. One of the legitimate comparisons between the two is from techharvest on Youtube. Remember that the operating system (WebOS) was something acquired from Palm about a year ago, so I wouldn’t compare old HP stuff to this device.

      1. It’s all about personal preference.

        I’ve been a loooong time Apple user (since the Apple II) and have always just preferred their products over others and absolutely love my iPad.

        I for one would love to see HP succeed with WebOS in this area, however I believe that there really isn’t a tablet market out there for other companies to sell their warez in; at least not for the general consumer. There will always be gadget freaks and technophiles who buy these products, but for the general consumer, there is only the iPad, just as with the iPod. So while other companies may do okay, they need to stop comparing themselves too the iPad.

  2. Does anything can be better than Apple products ? Sure not, you fanboys look harder under the hood of your mac’s , and you’ll see an inferior hardware that doesn’t cost a have of the price you pay. Windows laptop’s have a much better hardware for a price twice cheaper, all you pay is for the shiny exterior. Hah hah hah!

    1. Mike:
      Just making stuff up doesn’t work here. And Windows laptops have one major flaw that “apple’s” don’t: they’re stuck running Windoze. No one wants that anymore.

  3. Having seen one in action, I can verify that the things are obviously slow. And I’m not just talking Adobe Flash trash. The marketing behind the thing is HILARIOUS because they pulled the ridiculous trick of stating the OPPOSITE of what the gadget actually is, which of course invites the customer to test the claims, ALL of which FAIL miserably. Very bad show HP. Red ink for you.

    And it’s a shame that WebOS continues to suffer from bad hardware. It’s not a bad OS and eventually it may be the competitor we require against Apple’s iOS. But not in this outing! Hopefully with Jon Rubinstein out of the picture WebOS will flourish. He may well have been the source of its problems so far.

  4. All you fanboys are so blinded. I love Apple, but I’m objective. I don’t give a shit about any of you or Steve Jobs. When I pick something up, and start using it, if it’s great, it’s great, regardless of what logo is on it.

    I’ve been heavily involved in tablets for years. I owned the iPad 1 and have a lot of experience with other tablets. Tablets in business and for personal use. I tested the TouchPad last week and although I like the build quality on the iPad better, the TouchPad is really a great tablet. The best one out there next to the iPad.

    In terms of who people use a tablet, I get more done on the TouchPad than on the iPad. webOS is simply better on a tablet. When I go back to the iPad it’s so limiting in comparison. I like all the Apps, build quality, etc. with the iPad but the TouchPad has a lot of benefits.

    If you read actual user reviews, you’ll see that while there are some complaints of it being slow at first, it mostly subsides after they use the device for a few days. Now that Rubenstein is gone (socially inept idiot that he is), I have full confidence that webOS will have most of its kinks ironed out shortly.

    webOS, I predict, will have a stake in the ground in the tablet space because it’s a damn good operating system.

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.