“While there are a lot of video based hardware devices in the market all competing for the living room, today, none of them have the three essential components needed to be declared the winner,” Dan Rayburn writes for Streamingmedia.
“Because Apple wants to control not only the iTunes software but also the hardware, Apple is preventing themselves from ever controlling the living room,” Rayburn writes. “We know the hardware is becoming less important. Roku’s box is cheaper than Apple TV and offers support for USB and 1080p. So this is not about Apple having better hardware with Apple TV because they don’t. It’s about who has the best content and the best platform to manage it.”
“Apple is setting themselves up for failure in the living room all due to the fact that they feel they have to control everything in the video ecosystem. But just imagine if Apple cared less about the hardware and was more open with their iTunes platform. If Apple licensed iTunes to every TV and Blu-ray manufacturer and these devices all shipped with iTunes built in, Apple would immediately have the largest install base of anyone overnight,” Rayburn writes. “iTunes would become the dominant platform in the living room and could go uncontested if Apple added browser functionality to iTunes.”
“I like Apple devices, I’ve only used a Mac my whole life. But Apple makes some really dumb mistakes in the market at times simply due to their ego and this is one of those occasions,” Rayburn writes. “If Apple opened up iTunes to non-Apple devices, they would be dominating the market. And if they did that, and had the kind of device footprint Netflix will have by the end of this year, it would be a lot easier for Apple to get the studios to agree to allow them to add new business models like monthly subscriptions for video.”
Rayburn writes, “The competition to get consumers attention in the living room is wide open and with Google TV, Boxee and others all gearing up to launch their offerings, Apple’s iTunes platform and Apple TV device are only going to fall further behind in the race to control the connected living room.”
Full article here.
MacDailyNews Take: We highly doubt there’s an angle, especially one as obvious as this, that Steve Jobs hasn’t considered. If you want to question the strategy one of the greatest businessmen in history, go for it.
Just remember that market share is meaningless without healthy margins (i.e. revenue share). Dell and Nokia can tell you all about it.
In this case, we’re quite content to wait to see the rest of Jobs’ plan unfold (although we do wish he’d can the “hobby” talk as it just serves to create hesitation and inhibit sales). Meanwhile, Apple, hurry up and ship our Apple TVs already! Please?
[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Robert S.” for the heads up.]