MONKEYmedia sues Apple for patent infringement

invisibleSHIELD case for iPadMONKEYmedia today filed a lawsuit against Apple, Inc. for infringing claims in three of MONKEYmedia’s Seamless Contraction patents. Apple’s infringement involves its user interfaces for document summarization, RSS readers and video players that can display multiple versions of text and/or audiovisual content. The lawsuit was filed in the Western District of Texas – Austin Division.

“We can sit by and watch Apple continue to use our patented inventions without paying, or we can do something about it,” said Eric Gould Bear, MONKEYmedia’s CEO, in the press release.

Austin-based MONKEYmedia is a privately held user interface design studio turned intellectual property licensing boutique, founded in 1994 by Janna Buckmaster Bear and Eric Gould Bear, a Microsoft and Yahoo! alumnus, respectively.

Source: MONKEYmedia, Inc.

MacDailyNews Take: Licensing squeeze.

And Steve Jobs ought to sue wiseass Eric Gould Bear for plagiarism:

We can sit by and watch competitors steal our patented inventions, or we can do something about it.Steve Jobs, March 2, 2010

31 Comments

  1. Apple will get this monkey off their back in no time. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” /> (There, now the pun is out of the way.)

  2. Interesting, that it was filed in the western district of Texas, not the eastern patent mill. Come on Texas, stand up and squash the two little bears.

  3. this just in…
    Apple goes ape-s#!% on Monkeymedia, buys and sells their monkey-a$$es out if existenceband the world is better for it. Enjoy your retirement in the Bahamas MonkeyMedia!!! and remember it’s best to take a swim in the ocean right after a big meal. and after scuba diving you’ll want to get to the surface as quickly as possible!!

    They probably rightfully have a case. this stuff goes on everyday.

  4. So what happens when two different companies with similar (Ok the same patent with slightly different words) gets sued by both….???

    Do the courts have to figure out which one if any have a valid patent first?? ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

    Follow up thought. Apple keeps having patents approved. I am guessing that they are stiffing the patent courts with anything tied to their design, but that it takes a couple of years for the patent to wind its way thru the system.

    Just a thought,
    en

  5. Oh the responsibility of thinking of something first.

    That’s essentially what a patent is–proof you thought of something first.

    It DOES NOT mean you made or implemented something first.
    It DOES mean you have to defend your patent from every tom, dick and harry that uses or challenges it.
    It also DOES NOT mean you have the capital defend it.
    It MAY mean you can get paid for infringement by a second party
    it DOES NOT mean that that 2nd party has to stop using it.

    Where my lawyers at??? Is that about the jist of it?

  6. We all need to inundate congress with appeals to reform patents, copyright, and torts. Until then this ridiculousity will continue and severely stifle innovation. Contact your representatives now!

  7. @breeze

    I asked for a lawyer, not to be called ignorant.

    By your response, I take it you’re a lawyer?

    In which case you could have set me straight without attempting to insulting me.

    Maybe I should have asked for an adult.?

  8. It’s human nature. If anyone or a company is sitting on a
    pile of cash, others will try to get their hands on it by
    hook or crook.
    Has the final chapter been written on the Psystar fiasco?
    Was anyone financing them or did they act alone?

  9. @ silverhawk: Note the Eastern District of Texas is chosen for speed (all delaying motions will be rejected) and expertise, it is not a “patent mill”. It is the place to go if you have little money for lawyers or a slam dunk case.

    @MDN, where’s the link?

  10. One of the things we pay the Patent Office Examiners to do is make sure the content of a patent is unique. That is their job.

    However, their may be 10 different ways to do the same thing. I was involved in a patent to place two different colored images side by side on an image tube. One way took 15 components. Mine took two.

  11. Wow….its amazing all of these law suits coming against apple THREE YEARS after the iphone debut……

    I remember SJ re: the iphone interface and functionality at the 2007 Macworld debut and emphatically stating”and boy did we patent it”

    He knew the iphone (and future metephor devices) were going to be copied and the company be sued for “patent infringement”

    These companies see the writing on the wall, especially after the iPad debut and now selling like hot cakes. Apple was very smart at hiring that law firm to represent them.

    Good looking out Apple. With this latest “Monkey” lawsuit added to the rest, can we say that not only does apple have a Monkey on thier back….but they have they whole ZOO!!! ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.