Apple CEO Steve Jobs’ Macworld Expo keynote address ‘a colossal mistake’

“Steve Jobs’ blockbuster keynote address at last week’s Macworld was brilliantly and powerfully delivered — one of his best ever. It was also a colossal mistake,” Mike Elgan writes for Computerworld.

Elgan writes, “The keynote certainly looked familiar — the famous jeans and black turtleneck, the black background and giant screen. But Jobs did something unique with this speech: He announced, in detail, a major new product six months before its expected availability. Apple’s famous formula, successfully applied to dozens of iPod models, Macs and operating system rollouts, keeps details secret until products are ready to ship.”

“Sure, Jobs did the same thing — sort of — when he preannounced Apple TV back in September. But that speech lacked product details or even the correct brand name. Last week’s iPhone keynote was the first in Apple’s history in which a major new product line was unveiled in detail long before its actual ship date,” Elgan writes. “I think Jobs blew it.”

Elgan six reasons why:
1. Jobs raised buyer expectations too high
2. Jobs raised Wall Street expectations too high
3. Jobs gave competitors a head start
4. Jobs undermined Apple TV hype
5. Jobs put iPod sales at risk
6. Jobs wrecked Cisco talks

Full article here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “RadDoc” for the heads up.]

1. Debatable, but really a non-factor. Apple will initially sell as many as they can produce regardless and word of mouth/seeing the device in action will smooth out any out-of-whack expectations (too high or too low).
2. No. Apple’s goal of 10 million iPhones by 2008 is conservative and easily doable.
3. Patents.
4. Apple TV sits at #1 on Apple Store’s Best Sellers list.
5. Until the new multi-touch iPods debut, that is.
6. Who cares?

Related articles:
RUMOR: Apple to launch widescreen multi-touch iPod, Beatles deal via Super Bowl ad – January 19, 2007
Tognazzini: Glorious iPhone embodies the genius of Steve Jobs’ Apple – January 19, 2007
Researchers have bigger plans for ‘multi-touch’ beyond Apple’s iPhone – January 19, 2007
Ihnatko: Hands-on with Apple’s iPhone (which runs Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard) – January 18, 2007
Apple could potentially sell 30 million iPhones in 2007 – January 18, 2007
Reactions to iPhone highlight competitors’ inability to understand Apple’s success – January 17, 2007
ZDNet online poll shows overwhelming Apple iPhone lust – January 17, 2007
Apple iPhone tops Amazon’s bestselling electronics list in Germany – January 13, 2007
BusinessWeek explores ‘the real genius of Apple’s iPhone’ – January 12, 2007
Wired News: Steve Jobs’ iPhone shows the future – January 12, 2007
Cringely: Apple iPhone will suddenly go 3G, gain features, and be renamed ‘Apple Phone’ – January 12, 2007
Apple’s Phil Schiller gives CBS News hands-on tour of iPhone – January 12, 2007
20 unanswered questions about Apple’s iPhone – January 11, 2007
Report: iPhone could be upgraded to 3G with software update if Apple wishes – January 11, 2007
Report: Rogers Communications to offer Apple iPhone in Canada – January 11, 2007
David Pogue: hands on preview of Apple’s iPhone, ‘gorgeous and so packed with possibilities’ – January 11, 2007
PC Magazine hands-on test of Apple iPhone: multi-touch UI ‘takes the breath away’ – January 11, 2007
Mossberg’s initial take on Apple iPhone: ‘radical and gorgeous’ with ‘brilliant new user interface’ – January 11, 2007
NewsWeek’s Levy interviews Apple CEO Steve Jobs about iPhone – January 11, 2007
Why Apple’s iPhone doesn’t do high-speed mobile phone networks (yet) – January 11, 2007
RealMoney: Apple just blew up the whole damn mobile-phone supply chain with its new iPhone – January 11, 2007
ZDNet: Hands on with Apple’s iPhone: ‘elegant, ravishing, simple, sleek; impeccable & intuitive UI’ – January 11, 2007
Apple iPhone FUD campaign begins – January 10, 2007
Nine ways Apple changed the face of consumer electronics yesterday – January 10, 2007
Analysts and investors applaud arrival of Apple iPhone – January 10, 2007
Top 10 things to love and top 10 things to hate about the Apple iPhone – January 10, 2007
How Apple kept the iPhone top secret for 30 months – January 10, 2007
Hands-on with Apple’s iPhone – January 10, 2007
The only thing really wrong with Apple’s iPhone is its name – January 09, 2007
Is Apple building ‘The Device?’ [revisited] – January 09, 2007
Analyst Bajarin: Apple’s iPhone and Apple TV are industry game changers – January 09, 2007
Time: ‘iPhone could crush cell phone market pitilessly beneath the weight of its own superiority’ – January 09, 2007
Analyst: Apple iPhone should be given its own category – ‘brilliantphone’ – January 09, 2007
Cingular to use Synchronoss Technologies’ platform for Apple iPhone – January 09, 2007
iPhone photos from Apple’s Macworld Expo booth – January 09, 2007
Enderle: Apple’s iPhone is going to do very well – January 09, 2007
Apple debuts iPhone: touchscreen mobile phone + widescreen iPod + Internet communicator – January 09, 2007
Analyzing Apple’s iPhone market potential – January 15, 2007

Analyst: ‘iPhone’s willful disregard of global handset market will come back to haunt Apple’ – January 18, 2007
Microsoft CEO Ballmer laughs at Apple iPhone – January 17, 2007
Street Insight: Apple iPhone faces a number of potential obstacles – January 16, 2007
IDG News Service: ‘Reality might tarnish iPhone’s shine’ – January 16, 2007
The Times: Apple’s brand of corporate hubris is almost always damaging in the long run – January 16, 2007
Hackers ‘salivating’ over Apple’s iPhone – January 15, 2007
Bloomberg writer: Apple iPhone won’t make long-term mark; will only appeal to a few gadget freaks – January 15, 2007
Dvorak on Apple iPhone: ‘I think Apple can do wrong and I think this is it’ – January 13, 2007
USA Today writer: Apple iPhone is an ‘ordinary, average product’ at heart – January 12, 2007
FUD Alert: Analyst – I am pretty skeptical Apple’s iPhone can succeed – January 11, 2007
The massive FUD campaign against Apple’s iPhone ramps up – January 10, 2007
The Register’s Ray: Apple ‘iPhone’ will fail – December 26, 2006
Analyst: Apple iPhone economics aren’t that compelling – December 08, 2006
CNET editor Kanellos: ‘Apple iPhone will largely fail’ – December 07, 2006
Palm CEO laughs off Apple ‘iPhone’ threat – November 20, 2006

52 Comments

  1. Steve did the right thing! I have no worries and MDN is exactly right with their take.

    Magic Word: “figures” as in It figures some people wouldn’t see the brilliance in Steve’s move.

  2. Does ANYONE listen? My goodness, how often does Steve have to say it?

    The iPhone keynote WAS too early, and there are disadvantages to that. It was, however, unacceptable to let the FCC handle the initial iPhone publicity in the PUBLIC application for a license.

    Geez.

  3. Elgan!!! You are a knuklehead! Who says we have seen everything that the new iPhone is going to do. Apple still has months to add software and make even more improvements. Everyone I know wants one and can’t wait to get their hands on it!

  4. A mistake? Apple has had countless millions of publicity for iPhone and it hasn’t been leaked by the FCC. What’s that worth Elgan?

    And when it starts selling we’ll have him eating a large portion of humble pie.

    Remember Mike Elgan will say anything in the hope it rubs some dirt on Steve Jobs and Apple because when you’ve failed yourself, it becomes harder to give the other guy the credit.

  5. I’m unsure about whether it was a good thing or a bad thing. Yes, he did let the cat out of the bag to his competitors, but it took Apple almost three years to develop it, and they’ve got the patents to protect it.

    It will also give people six months to start saving their money for the phone, and start trying to get out of their contracts with other carriers, or let them expire.

    Of course, damned if I’ll get a iPod 5G now. But I’ve been hearing so many rumors about the 6G during the last year, that I wouldn’t have gotten one anyway.

    I’m just thankful that I don’t have to listen to another six months of iPod speculation, innuendo and rumors. Now, they’ll finally have something else to talk about on TWIT…

  6. this guy is an idiot:

    1. Jobs raised buyer expectations too high
    2. Jobs raised Wall Street expectations too high
    3. Jobs gave competitors a head start
    4. Jobs undermined Apple TV hype
    5. Jobs put iPod sales at risk
    6. Jobs wrecked Cisco talks

    1. All he did was demo the product. He didnt talk about features that arent in the phone, they are all working features now. Any hype created was merely by people getting excited over the devices current working features. How will he dash their hopes? Remove feattures?
    2. Apple ALWAYS sets low guidance for their upcoming fiscal quarters. This quarter was no different.
    3. Those competitors will have to undergo a LOOONG development cycle to get anything even similar out the door. This notion that compaies can whip something like this out in a month shows vast ignorance. Plus they will also have to get FCC approval on any device that answers the iPhone.
    4 Yeah thats why the AppleTV is the number one selling electronic product on Amazon right now.
    5 most people dont buy $500 ipods. Most people who buy high end ipods want their entire collections on one ipod, which the iPhone doesnt do.
    6 who gives a crap. Theres no proof that Cisco even holds the trademark anyway.

  7. The “Big Mistake” in here is that Elgan did not make his homework, May be Macworld was a big mistake for an Ignorant that does not know how sales works (there is a book called “Sales for dummies”, could be alittle complicated for Elgan, but may work), but for Real People, the iPod and iTV was one of the latest big hit of apple.

  8. It would have been leaked by the FCC in any case, there’s no way the iPhone would have sneaked through unnoticed. Cingular would need more access and information closer to launch and I can’t see them not leaking.

    Pre-announcing phone’s is common practise in the industry. It also gives Apple plenty of time to negotiate the international deals and get features like the voice mail implemented in time.

  9. He had to show it. Otherwise, details would have been leaked for sure during the FCC certification period and pre-launch production. Also, he did it in the past, too. Remember the iPod mini? The G5 Powermac? They were all presented as working prototypes, yet it took several months for them to appear on the shelves in quantities.
    As for the competitors, that’s a toss-up. Sure, they know what they’ll have to compete with, but they will also be shell-shocked. There’s an avalanche of patent applications by Apple looming over everybody who plans anything similar.
    Also, by giving consumers a glimpse of what the immediate future holds, he gave them a reason to postpone the next cell phone purchase, creating a pent-up demand for this summer that will soak up the first iPhone shipments.
    Mike Elgan is a tech journalist with no clue about marketing. What does he know!

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.