Blogger: Apple’s ‘Touché – Macs Do Windows Too’ TV ad is ‘lame, smug, arrogant, and possibly wrong’

“The new Apple ad annoys me. (Touché) It exudes the kind of smugness that a lot of people associate with Mac users, and the nit-pickiness of the definition of ‘touché’ alienates people. Hell — I wasn’t previously aware that the term is that specific (a point made in rebuttal to another point, according to the commercial), so I looked it up online and couldn’t find a reference that mentions that specifically. Hell, Apple’s own dictionary app (using the Oxford English Dictionary) doesn’t mention it,” Jammer blogs for The Welblog.

Jammer opines, “Lame. Smug, arrogant, and possibly wrong. Get rid of the ad, Apple.”

Full article with screenshot here.

Apple’s “Touché” ad:

MacDailyNews Note: “Used as an acknowledgment during a discussion of a good or clever point made at one’s expense by another person” certainly describes the poor PC’s reaction to the Mac’s statements in Apple’s “Touché” ad. Jammer’s right about that part. We wouldn’t put it past Apple to intentionally use it wrong – we are talking about it now aren’t we?

The ad’s real point, that Macs run Windows and are the only computer you’ll ever need, seems slightly muddied by the whole “touché” discussion, but not muddied enough to hurt. The ad is still powerful. This ad works, “touché” right or wrong, because it dangles the “twofer” right in front of the publics’ collective face. Certainly, Apple’s “Touché” ad is not lame, smug, or arrogant.

There is simply no defense against, “Now you can run Mac OS X or Windows on a Mac, so it’s the only computer you’ll ever need.”

The “Embrace” phase of Apple’s plan is off to a strong start.

As we see it, Apple is executing a two-part “Embrace and Extinguish” plan. Give people their Windows “insecurity blanket” first. They believe they need Windows and cannot be convinced otherwise. Let them find out for themselves what Mac OS X and Apple’s Mac-only apps like iLife, Safari, etc. are all about. Then, when the time comes to buy their next Mac, they’ll be just like us: they won’t even care if it can run Windows. We are extremely confident that Mac OS 10.4 Tiger will win converts from Windows XP. Heck, for that matter, we’re extremely confident that Mac OS X 10.2 Jaguar would win converts from Windows XP. Leopard vs. Windows Vista? It’ll be no contest. We’ve seen it happen in real life too many times: let someone really use a Mac for a couple of weeks and they simply do not want to go back to Windows.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
Apple debuts three new ‘Get a Mac’ ads (with video) – June 12, 2006
Dude, you got a Dell? What are you, stupid? Only Apple Macs run both Mac OS X and Windows!
Why buy a Dell when Apple’s Intel-based computers will run both Mac OS X and Windows? – June 08, 2005

188 Comments

  1. There will always be somebody that is going to complain about something. Jammer is one of those somebodies.

    Frankly his ‘complaints’ about the ad makes me think he’s insecure about something, and is taking that insecurity out on Apple.

  2. I see no need to complain about this commercial. It sends the message clearly. Mac users now can enjoy multiple OS’s AND still have the best OS available (Mac OS X). Maybe there’s a reason to be smug. When you got it you got it and when you don’t you nit pick like Jammer is doing. I hope he can get his panties to un-bunch.

  3. Have you noticed that the attacks are less and less about the actual platform and more and more about something trivial. Must be scary on that side of things to have to dig deeper and deeper to find something negative to say.

  4. I checked three sources on this, they all agree that the Apple ad is wrong. Then I saw this in Wikipedia: More commonly it is used sarcastically to indicate that one is unable to argue against another’s absurd logic. This use is most often restricted to scripted satirical media such as political cartoons, comic strips and comedy shows.
    Hmmm, maybe they know about the Ad Business?

    Greg Thurman may be right in saying that: There will always be somebody that is going to complain about something. Jammer is one of those somebodies., but that does not invalidate everything he says. The entire series of ads is a bit arrogant. This one more so than the others. We’re a group who feels superior to “Windows Lemmings/Sheep” and don’t mind if others know it. That’s part of what the ads are selling – the right to feel superior! You didn’t really think it was about Mac minis or MacBooks, did you? Do you recall seeing an actual Mac in any of the ads? All you see/hear is the idea of a Mac.

  5. It is obvious to informed and intelligent people that Macs can run both OS X and Windows. I acknowledge that some Windows-based applications may not run as fast on a Mac as on a PC, but I know of none. In addition, Jammer doesn’t provide any real evidence that Macs cannot be used as well as PCs in running Windows-based applications. Instead, Jammer’s complaint appears to be more emotional than logical. Jammer ought to relieved that blogging affords anonymity. His comments are senseless.

  6. I’m not sure about Jammer’s complaint. However, there is no reason “Mac” has to be correct about use of the word touché.

    Derived from French, “to touch” or “touched,” it was originally used in fencing to acknowledge an opponent having scored a point or a touch.

    Thus, “PC’s” use of the word simply helps drive the point home.

    Mac: “Now you can buy a Mac and still use all your Windows stuff.”

    PC: “Touché!”

    I guess we just have to let go of the idea that Mac computers are perfect in all ways. Even if they are actors in a commercial.

  7. it paints a real bad image, in my mind, of a Mac trying to be a know-it-all and failing, so now he’s just the guy who tries to act like he knows everything but really doesn’t. I really hate those guys, and I do not want to be associated as one of them just because I use a better computer operating system…..

    I like all the other ads though.

  8. Windows cry babies.

    Hey, no one wants to be wrong. Just admit you bought the wrong computer when you were not paying attention and invested in a Windows PC.

    Get a Mac and move on with life. Why wait for Windows to improve?

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.