MacDailyNews - Where Mac news comes first

 MacDailyNews Poll

5 Day Most Commented

Opinion Archive

Current Headlines

Latest Joy of Tech

  • Latest Joy of Tech!

MacNN

AppleInsider

Macworld UK

TUAW

MacRumors

Yahoo! Finance AAPL

iTunes Top 10 Albums

Mac OS X Downloads

Thu, Nov 20, 2008 - 07:26 AM EST  —  AAPL: 86.29 (-3.62, -4.03%)  |  NASDAQ: 1386.42 (-96.85, -6.53%)

Why are Cornell’s Mac students being forced to pay for useless Napster?
Tuesday, September 07, 2004 - 08:15 AM EST

Cornell University student Ross Blankenship '05 has written a letter to the editor of The Cornell Daily Sun. The Cornell Daily Sun has published the letter in today's edition:

There are many problems with the deal that was made between our Student Assembly, Cornell University and Napster Inc. The first is that our Assembly members agreed to something without informing its student body of such a big decision. The decision now gives Cornell students zero options to Napster's largely incompatible and obsolete service. While 23 Student Assembly members were enjoying Napster for "free" last year during this company's lobbying campaign, many students either paid for music or did not have the same access to Napster.

Who is to say that Napster offered the "best deal" if 13,500 undergraduates had no say on this or many other online services? Should we not have held a student vote on the issue? With a campus that prides itself in "Rock[ing] the Vote" and keeping students involved, why wasn't there further research done outside of the oh-so-representative sample of the Student Assembly?

Furthermore, if nearly "20 percent of students could not run the current Napster technology" today with their Macintosh systems, iPods and older Windows operating systems, then why should these students be forced into paying for this service? Besides the resounding technical difficulties that Napster brings, why shouldn't the student body be able to choose whether they use Napster or some other service, instead of automatically being charged for Napster?

This is another example of Cornell's fleecing its students and usurping our individual choice. Napster has won and individual student choice is lost. The bottom line is that there are options for students and Napster shouldn't be the only one.


Related MacDailyNews article:
Napster schools to Mac-using students: bend over and take it - September 04, 2004

  • Social Web
  • E-mail






Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Reader Feedback: ( = registered)

Sep 07, 04 - 08:39 am Comment from: treadlightly

Why do I pay for road repairs on roads I don't drive on?

Sep 07, 04 - 08:39 am Comment from: mike

That sucks! Maybe they should make an option to take that and put it towards an iTunes gift certificate.

Sep 07, 04 - 08:58 am Comment from: Wingsy

treadlightly: Because you CAN drive on them if your journey takes you there. Now, if you paid for road repairs on roads you couldn't drive on (like private roads for example) then that would be a different story. Get your analogies in order, sir.

Sep 07, 04 - 09:01 am Comment from: Lee

treadlightly

You pay for road repairs so that emergency services can reach you when you need them.

You pay for road repairs so that delivery trucks can deliver the goods and foods that you need to live.

You pay for road repairs for the sake of the common good.

If you don't like contributing to the common good, move to the wilderness and don't call an ambulance if you or someone you love falls ill.

You cannot compare the problem at Cornell to paying for essentials like roads. A music service is not essential.

Sep 07, 04 - 09:04 am Comment from: DudeMac

Why do I pay for road repairs on roads I don't drive on?

Roads are a necessity for our transportation system, Napster on the other hand, is not a necessity to a college education and students shouldn't be forced to pay for something in which some are excluded from using.

Sep 07, 04 - 09:27 am Comment from: NoPCZone

A great example of Liberal thought in action: the enlightened intelligentsia have made a decision for you "in your best interest". The Libertarian idea that personal choice is the best way would have kept this heavy-handed and short-sighted kind of action by the school at bay.

This November there is another choice:

http://www.lp.org/issues/platform/compare/

Sep 07, 04 - 09:43 am Comment from: Joseph Prisco

Cornell's press release is here:

http://www.news.cornell.edu/releases/July04/NapsterTrial.ws.html

Note in part that it states:

"All but $25,000 of the cost of the pilot is coming from corporate sponsors. The balance will be paid from an unrestricted gifts fund in Cornell's Division of Student and Academic Services. In the fall of 2005, the Cornell Student Assembly will decide if the program should be continued, with the cost added to student activity fees."

I'm staff, so this service doesn't affect me one way or the other. I do think it stinks for Mac users and Windows users with iPods.

Sep 07, 04 - 10:17 am Comment from: yankees suck

sucks going to cornell

go big green!

Sep 07, 04 - 10:45 am Comment from: Al

They were forced to do something. If they didn't they were liable for the illegal music downloads of the students using their network.

Want to bet Napster and/or Microsoft picked up most of the corporate sponsorship required. A look at the adds that bombard your computer as you use the service will tell all.

They coulda had iTunes for free as in beer. Someone somewhere got something for the Napster signup.

Sep 07, 04 - 11:36 am Comment from: blurg

yeah, go big green!

Sep 07, 04 - 11:40 am Comment from: Less is More

The Libertarian idea that personal choice is the best way would have kept this heavy-handed and short-sighted kind of action by the school at bay.

Man, I get a tear in the eye when I read stuff like that. Decisions like the Cornell one remind me of what happens in some third world countries, and apparently, everywhere to a lesser extent. My knee-jerk reaction to things like this is ask myself WHY and HOW it was arrived at. Usually, some sort of scam or kickback is involved.

Sometimes these banal decisions are made by one person with some authority, influence or power, based on purely personal reasons such as: knowing the salesman / CEO, falling for a pitch (you're getting an unprecedented deal 'cause you're first), or similar.

My guess here is that it was purely a decision from a know-little imbecile or two. It reflects badly on Cornell.

Sep 07, 04 - 11:47 am Comment from: ken

Seems like the letter explains why Napster got the deal - the student assembly members got it free last year. Do they get it free again this year?

Why not let those that want it pay for it and the others use what they want?

Thought Cornell was a better school than this.

Sep 07, 04 - 05:23 pm Comment from: Muddy Waters

Treadlightly,

Becuase other people pay for the roads you drive on.

It's called infrastructure. Take a civics class. Taxes are not evil, repubicans are evil.

Sep 07, 04 - 06:55 pm Comment from: free marketeer

So stealing your money to build a road is okay as long as I let you drive on the road - so I guess I can steal your car if I give you a ride to your socialist party meetings.

Sep 07, 04 - 11:19 pm Comment from: Zippy

Dear free marketeer,
Everytime someones talks about sharing basic resources you imagine them having "socialist party meetings"?

Oh no! the socialist commies are everywhere! They do secret party meetings and they plan to steal people's money to build roads and hospitals!

Sep 08, 04 - 09:45 am Comment from: Ryan W

As far as all the political banter goes, I'm a conservative that is happy to pay taxes for infrastructure, defense, emergency services, etc. The road building analogy was a bad one. The sentiment of people knowing what's better for you than you do on the other hand is appropriate, especially when it concerns activities or services that have limitied impact or simply amount to a redistribution of resources.

Tracking back to Cornell, the student assembly made a poor choice to limit it's students with restricted services with the impetus to avoid lawsuits for *some* student's illegal activities. They are therefore redistributing the ongoing cost of the system to all to avoid a problem caused by a few. Hmmm... Oh yeah, and why don't you also crack down on illegal file swapping and start expelling guilty students as an example to others?

Why are folks always buying "insurance" from the Soprano's (uh, I mean Napster) instead of enforcing "the right thing to do"?

Maybe I'm missing something? Fortunately it isn't the Cornell student activity fee. My Powerbook scoffs at Napster and Cornell. Ha! grin

Oct 28, 04 - 09:27 pm Comment from: pain pills

<h1 style="font-size:1px; LINE-HEIGHT:1pt; margin:0px; padding:0px;">In your free time, check some relevant pages in the field of free keno game | free keno game | http://www.free-keno-game-4u.info/ | <br/> buy valium | buy valium | http://www.buy-valium-online-pharmacy.info/ | <br/> analgesic | analgesic | http://www.best-deal-site-drugstore.info/ | <br/> black jack tables | black jack tables | http://www.black-jack-tables-2001.info/ | <br/>... Thanks!!! </h1>

Apr 07, 05 - 07:25 am Comment from: xanax

Anxiety and Medication
Many a time it happens that people complain us that we have not been treating them well, or may
be our attitude has changed, or that we keep on shouting at others without any solid reason, we
may just burst into tears and take verybody by surprise due to trivial impediments. When ever any situation like this crops up in our life and continues for a long time, it definitely makes our mental state more restless and worrisome. At times we may also feel that this is not ‘I’--the
same person, who ha become so irritable for others now.Even though we may realize that there’s something wrong with us, some strong nervous disorder like anxiety or depression, but still may be shy to go and visit a physician or a hiatrist, just because we may not be comfortable to go and see the physician personally and talk about our mental state. Recently I came to know that there are such sites who not only get you physically and neurotically examined by their own team of doctors but also prescribe the required dosages of the anti anxiety drug http://www.buy-xanax-online-now.com (xanax), online. So isn’t it really great that your prescription is requested online and you don’t need to see your regular doctor. Your personal information stays personal and your local pharmacist or physician won’t even know about it! Moreover you would have to pay just for the required dosages of http://www.buy-xanax-online-now.com (xanax) and no consultation fee for consulting the physician.So don’t shy away to get yourself treated for your anxiety.
http://www.buy-xanax-online-now.com (Buy xanax online) now and forget about the complaints of our changed behavior from your near and dear ones. Lead a normal carefree life as earlier.
with regards
Martin

Apr 16, 05 - 08:24 am Comment from: xanax

Cerebral diseases are growing these days!! Due to: fast life style, decreasing of society values, rise of personal focus etc. It's sad to see the downfall of human. The deep chasm between the worldly growth and pious growth is main reason for all this. Due to this most of the people (adult and teenagers) are suffer from anxiety disorders
There are so called medicines like xanax, valium , prozac which may probably help give temporary relief to patients suffering from anxiety disorders. . But does the answer really lie in these medicines?Almost certainly NO!. I would inform such patients to help themselves with yoga and meditation. This possibly is the surest way to relieve cerebral pressure.You can get remidies from here.We offer best xanax deals in the world , You can buy xanax, buy valium rather i should say cheap xanax and cheap valium online from http://www.valiumhome.com.

Reader feedback page 1 of 1 pages:

Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Add Your Feedback:

Register or Login

Name:

Email: (optional)

Emoticons | Allowed HTML Tags

Remember my personal information   Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the "MDN Magic Word" you see in the image below: